Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2009 / iii / Paper 10 / 2 / Solution

A completely regular Hausdorff space is a Hausdorff space in which each point $x$ outside a closed set $F$ is separated from $F$ by a continuous function $u:X\to [0,1]$ with $u(x)=1$ and $u{|}_F=0$. Put $E=C_b(X)$ and define the evaluation character by ${\delta }_x(g)=g(x)$. The weak-star topology on $E^{\prime }$ is the topology of pointwise convergence on $E$: its coordinate maps $p\mapsto p(g)$ are continuous, and generate the topology. It is Hausdorff, and the dual unit ball is compact in it by the Banach-Alaoglu theorem.

For nonempty $X$, $\Vert {\delta }_x\Vert =1$ by the supremum norm bound and the constant function $1$. All the coordinates of $x\mapsto {\delta }_x$ are continuous, so $\delta$ is continuous. Complete regularity separates distinct points, proving injectivity. To prove continuity of the inverse onto its image, let $x\in O$ with $O$ open in $X$. Separating $x$ from $X\setminus O$ gives a bounded continuous $u$ withSuch neighborhoods prove that $\delta$ is a homeomorphism onto $\delta (X)$. This qualification is essential: it is not onto the whole dual, since the zero functional is not an evaluation on a nonempty space.

Define the Stone-Čech compactification to beThe Banach-Alaoglu theorem makes this a compact Hausdorff space, with $X$ identified with its dense evaluation copy. For $g\in C_b(X)$, the coordinate function $\tilde{g}(p)=p(g)$ is a continuous extension. Density gives $\Vert \tilde{g}{\Vert }_{\infty }=\Vert g{\Vert }_{\infty }$. Conversely any $h\in C(\beta X)$ restricts to an element $g$ of $C_b(X)$, and $h=\tilde{g}$ because they agree on the dense subset $X$. Restriction and coordinate extension are inverse linear isometries, henceThey also preserve products: the corresponding continuous functions agree on $X$ and hence everywhere.

For the universal extension property, let $f:X\to K$ be continuous and $K$ a compact Hausdorff space. Pullback defines a bounded linear operator $T:C(K)\to C_b(X)$ by $Tg=g\circ f$. Its dual map $T^{\prime }:E^{\prime }\to C(K{)}^{\prime }$ is weak-star continuous, since $(T^{\prime }p)(g)=p(Tg)$. Evaluation ${\delta }_K:K\to C(K{)}^{\prime }$ is a homeomorphism onto a compact, thus closed, subset: a compact Hausdorff space is completely regular, by the Urysohn lemma. Now $T^{\prime }{\delta }_x={\delta }_K(f(x))$, soTherefore $\overline{f}={\delta }_K^{-1}\circ T^{\prime }{|}_{\beta X}$ is the required continuous extension. Two continuous maps into the Hausdorff space $K$ agreeing on the dense subset $X$ agree everywhere, proving uniqueness.

If $X$ is open in $\beta X$, then it is a locally compact space: around any $x$, regularity of the compact Hausdorff space $\beta X$ gives an open neighborhood whose closure is compact and lies in $X$. Conversely, suppose $X$ is locally compact. Choose an open neighborhood $U$ of $x$ in $X$ with compact closure $C\subseteq X$. There is an open $O\subseteq \beta X$ with $O\cap X=U$. Density of $X$ implies $O\subseteq {\overline{U}}^{\beta X}$, while compactness of $C$ makes it closed in $\beta X$, so ${\overline{U}}^{\beta X}\subseteq C$. Thus $x\in O\subseteq X$. This provesThe empty-space cases are immediate.

The final printed assertion, for an arbitrary subset of $\beta X$, is false. Take the infinite discrete space $X=\mathbb{N}$. It is not compact, so its compactification has a point $p\in \beta \mathbb{N}\setminus \mathbb{N}$. The singleton $\{p\}$ is closed, hence equals its own closure. It is not open, since every nonempty open subset of $\beta \mathbb{N}$ meets the dense copy of $\mathbb{N}$. This is a counterexample.

The valid result holds for subsets $D\subseteq X$, and more generally for open subsets of $\beta X$. For $D\subseteq X$, its indicator is bounded continuous because $X$ is discrete. Its extension $\widetilde{1_D}$ is still idempotent by density, so it takes only the values zero and one. The set $H=\{\widetilde{1_D}=1\}$ is clopen and has $H\cap X=D$. Density then gives $H={\overline{D}}^{\beta X}$. If $O$ is open in $\beta X$, the set $O\cap X$ is dense in $O$, so $\overline{O}=\overline{O\cap X}$ is clopen by the result just proved. Consequently $\beta X$ is extremally disconnected, which means the closure of every open set is open. This is the discrete Stone-Čech compactifications are extremally disconnected theorem, with the essential open-set qualification.