Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2010 / iii / Paper 7 / 3 / d / Solution

The positive sign printed in the exponential uses the skew-adjoint convention for the Dirac operator: $D^{\ast }=-D$, so $D_{-}=-D_{+}^{\ast }$. Put $A=D_{+}$ and define the nonnegative self-adjoint operatorsFor $t>0$, the assumed compact elliptic spectral theorem for these elliptic differential operators gives discrete eigenvalues, finite multiplicities and trace-class operators $e^{-tP}$, $e^{-tQ}$.

If $Pu=\lambda u$ with $\lambda >0$, then $Q(Au)=A(Pu)=\lambda Au$ and $Au\ne 0$. Conversely $A^{\ast }$ sends the $\lambda$ eigenspace of $Q$ to that of $P$. On these eigenspaces the inverse of $A$ is ${\lambda }^{-1}{A}^{\ast }$. Thus the positive spectra agree with multiplicity, and absolute convergence of the operator traces permits cancellation term by term:The last expression is the Fredholm index of $A$, since its closed range has orthogonal complement $\ker A^{\ast }$. ConsequentlyThis is the supertrace cancellation used in Question 1. If the Dirac operator is instead defined to be self-adjoint, $D_{-}=(D_{+}{)}^{\ast }$ and the heat exponentials must have a minus sign. With that convention the positive exponentials in the printed formula are generally unbounded and have no finite operator trace.