Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 18 / 4 / b

Put $e_A={\epsilon }_{FA}F{\eta }_A$. This is a natural transformation $F\Rightarrow F$. Only the $G$-triangle $G{\epsilon }_D{\eta }_{GD}=1_{GD}$ is assumed. Naturality gives two useful absorption identities:For the second equality in the last line use naturality of $\epsilon$ at ${\epsilon }_D$, and then the assumed $G$-triangle. Naturality of $\epsilon$ at $F{\eta }_A$ and of $\eta$ at ${\eta }_A$ now givesHence $e$ is an idempotent in the functor category: this is the one-triangle adjunction idempotent.

For the splitting of an idempotent morphism, suppose this idempotent morphism splits as natural transformations $r:F\Rightarrow H$ and $s:H\Rightarrow F$, with $sr=e$ and $rs=1_H$. DefineThe first absorption identity givesFor the other triangle, naturality of $s$ at ${\eta }_A^{\prime }$ and of $\epsilon$ at $r_A$ givesThus the triangle identities for an adjunction prove $H⊣G$.

Conversely, suppose $H⊣G$, with unit $\psi :1_{\mathcal{C}}\Rightarrow GH$ and counit $\phi :HG\Rightarrow 1_{\mathcal{D}}$. The unit has target $GH$, as its type requires. DefineThese are natural transformations. Transposition under $H⊣G$ gives $G{s}_A{\psi }_A={\eta }_A$. Independently, naturality of $\eta$ at ${\psi }_A$ and the assumed $G$-triangle giveThe transpose of $r_A{s}_A$ is therefore $G{r}_{A}G{s}_A{\psi }_A={\psi }_A$, the transpose of $1_{HA}$. Injectivity of the hom-set bijection implies $r_A{s}_A=1_{HA}$. Naturality of $\epsilon$ at $s_A$ givesConsequently $G$ has a left adjoint if and only if $e$ splits. This is the criterion for splitting a one-triangle adjunction idempotent. The argument gives both the explicit splitting and the new unit and counit, without assuming the other triangle for $F$.