Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 32 / 1 / e / Solution

Let $X$ and $Y$ denote the first- and second-stage sample means, let $s=\sigma /\sqrt{n}$, and write $S=(X+Y)/2$. Continuation is the selection event $\mathcal{C}=\{X\ge sf\}$. The second-stage sample mean stays independent of $\mathcal{C}$, so $E(Y\mid \mathcal{C})=\delta$. The first-stage sample mean has a truncated normal distribution. With $a=f-\delta /s$ and the upper-tail Inverse Mills ratio $\lambda (a)=\varphi (a)/(1-\Phi (a))$,The positive conditional selection bias after futility continuation comes from selecting unusually large first-stage outcomes. The unconditional sample mean of a fixed $2n$ observations would be unbiased; that is a different sampling distribution from the one restricted to continued trials.

As $\delta \to \infty$, $a\to -\infty$, $\varphi (a)\to 0$ and $1-\Phi (a)\to 1$, so the estimator bias tends to zero. It decreases with $\delta$: differentiating gives ${\lambda }^{\prime }(a)=\lambda (a)(\lambda (a)-a)>0$, because $\lambda (a)=E(Z\mid Z>a)>a$ for a standard normal random variable. Thus