Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 65 / 3 / a / Solution

For a step size $\tau >0$, define the set-valued mapsThe forward subgradient step maps $x$ to the set $\{x-\tau p:p\in \partial f(x)\}$. If $f$ is differentiable this is the explicit gradient step $x-\tau \nabla f(x)$. The backward subgradient step consists of the $y$ satisfying $x-y\in \tau \partial f(y)$, an implicit step for the subgradient flow. It is the resolvent of a monotone operator associated with $\partial f$.

Suppose $y_1,y_2\in B_{\tau f}(x)$. Then $p_i=(x-y_i)/\tau \in \partial f(y_i)$. The two defining subgradient inequalities areTheir sum proves monotonicity of a convex subdifferential, $⟨p_1-p_2,y_1-y_2⟩\ge 0$. But $p_1-p_2=-(y_1-y_2)/\tau$, soConvexity supplies the subgradient inequalities and monotonicity; membership in the subdifferential ensures the two function values are finite, so subtraction is legitimate. Positivity of $\tau$ supplies the decisive sign. Properness rules out the identically infinite and negative-infinity pathologies in the overall setting, but lower semicontinuity is not needed for this at-most-one argument. Its role is in existence, proved next. The backward step cannot have two values, though uniqueness alone has not yet shown its domain is all of ${\mathbb{R}}^n$.