Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2015 / ii / Paper 2 / 22G / Solution

An immersion $\varphi :U\to {\mathbb{R}}^3$ has differential of rank $2$, equivalently linearly independent ${\varphi }_u,{\varphi }_v$. It has isothermal coordinates when its first fundamental form has $E=G>0$, $F=0$. A minimal surface has zero mean curvature.

For an isothermal immersion, differentiation of $E=G$ and $F=0$ givesand similarly its scalar product with ${\varphi }_v$ is zero. Its normal component is $e+g$. The given mean curvature formula reduces to $H=(e+g)/(2E)$, soThus an isothermal immersion is minimal exactly when each coordinate is a harmonic function.

An explicit example is the Enneper surface, parametrized on ${\mathbb{R}}^2$ byEvery coordinate has zero Laplacian. Direct differentiation gives ${\varphi }_u\cdot {\varphi }_v=0$ and $|{\varphi }_u{|}^2=|{\varphi }_v{|}^2=(1+u^2+v^2{)}^2>0$. Thus it is an isothermal immersion and is minimal everywhere.

It is not an open subset of any of the three listed surfaces. The parameter points $(\sqrt{3},0)$ and $(-\sqrt{3},0)$ both map to $(0,0,3)$, but their tangent planes differ: ${\varphi }_u=(-2,0,\pm 2\sqrt{3})$ while ${\varphi }_v=(0,4,0)$. A plane, catenoid, or helicoid is an embedded smooth surface with a unique tangent plane at each point. If our whole image lay in any one of them, both rank-$2$ tangent planes at this point would have to equal its tangent plane, a contradiction.