Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2017 / ii / Paper 2 / 16I (Galois Theory)

A finite field extension $L/K$ is a separable field extension if every element of $L$ has a minimal polynomial over $K$ with distinct roots in an algebraic closure. The primitive element theorem says that a finite separable field extension $L/K$ is $K(\alpha )$ for some $\alpha \in L$.

If $K$ is finite, then so is $L$. The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, so a generator of $L^{\times }$ generates $L$ as a field. To justify the group fact, a finite subgroup of a field's multiplicative group is cyclic: in a finite abelian group its exponent is attained as an element order, while the polynomial root bound forces its size to be at most that exponent.

If $K$ is infinite, first consider $L=K(a,b)$. The minimal polynomials of $a$ and $b$ have distinct roots $a_i,b_j$ in an algebraic closure. Choose $c\in K$, $c\ne 0$, avoiding the finitely many values for which $a_i+c{b}_j=a+cb$ for a pair other than $(a,b)$. Set $\alpha =a+cb$. Over $K(\alpha )$, the polynomials $f(T)$ and $g((\alpha -T)/c)$ have precisely one common root, $a$. Their monic greatest common divisor is therefore $T-a$, so $a\in K(\alpha )$ and $b=(\alpha -a)/c\in K(\alpha )$. Thus $K(a,b)=K(\alpha )$. Induct over finitely many generators of the finite separable field extension. This proves every finite separable extension is simple.

Put $a=\sqrt{p}$, $b=\sqrt{-q}$ and $\alpha =a+b$. Since $a^2-b^2=p+q$, the identity $(a+b)(a-b)=p+q$ givesThus $\mathbb{Q}(\alpha )=\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{p},\sqrt{-q})$. The latter has degree $4$: $p$ is not a square and $\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{p})$ is real, whereas $\sqrt{-q}$ is not real. Squaring ${\alpha }^2=p-q+2\sqrt{-pq}$ gives its monic degree-$4$ minimal polynomial

In characteristic $p$, let $K={\mathbb{F}}_p(s,t)$ and $L={\mathbb{F}}_p(s^{1/p},t^{1/p})$, with $s,t$ having algebraic independence. The monomials $s^{i/p}{t}^{j/p}$, $0\le i,j<p$, form a $K$-basis, so $[L:K]=p^2$. Their independence follows by grouping polynomial monomials according to their exponents modulo $p$, after clearing rational-function denominators.

Every $\alpha \in L$ has ${\alpha }^p\in K$, so its minimal polynomial divides $T^p-{\alpha }^p$ and $[K(\alpha ):K]\le p$. Thus this finite purely inseparable extension has no primitive element. It demonstrates why the separable field extension hypothesis cannot simply be removed.