Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2017 / iii / Paper 107 / 3 / b / Solution

Let $L=\Delta +c$ with real $c$, and letThe Fredholm alternative for an elliptic Dirichlet problem says that $N$ is finite-dimensional. If $N=0$, all the prescribed data admit a unique solution. In general the exact boundary compatibility in the self-adjoint Fredholm alternative isThese conditions are necessary and sufficient; when they hold, all solutions form $u_0+N$. Thus in the second branch some data are incompatible, while compatible data have nonunique solutions. The outward normal derivative fixes the displayed sign.

To prove the alternative, put $X=\{w\in C^{2,\alpha }(\overline{\Omega }):w{|}_{\partial \Omega }=0\}$ and $Y=C^{0,\alpha }(\overline{\Omega })$. The standard zero-boundary Poisson equation theorem makes $\Delta :X\to Y$ an isomorphism. Multiplication by $c$, followed by ${\Delta }^{-1}$, is a compact operator $K:X\to X$: the embedding $C^{2,\alpha }\hookrightarrow C^{0,\alpha }$ is compact, and multiplication is bounded. Writing $u=\psi +w$ givesThe Fredholm alternative for a compact operator implies finite kernel and cokernel of equal dimension, and invertibility exactly when the kernel vanishes.

For the explicit compatibility conditions, use the self-adjoint Dirichlet realization of $L$ on $L^2$. It has compact resolvent: a sufficiently large positive shift of $-L$ is coercive, its inverse gains two derivatives, and the Rellich-Kondrachov compactness theorem makes that inverse compact. The Fredholm solvability condition for a self-adjoint operator is $F\perp N$. Standard boundary elliptic regularity upgrades the resulting weak solution to $C^{2,\alpha }$ for these data and boundary. Thus it gives the same kernel and solvability as the preceding Hölder-space formulation.

Finally Green second identity, with $z=0$ on the boundary and $Lz=0$, givesConsequently $\int zF=\int zf+\int \psi {\partial }_{\nu }z$, proving both necessity and sufficiency with the stated sign. If using complex data and real $c$, replace $z$ by $\overline{z}$ in the pairings.