Past exam of the probability, statistics and options I course of the University of Oxford / 2011 / O / 2 / c

The total $S$ under $H_0$ has Poisson distribution with mean $12$, and the observed total is $16$. Its one-sided p-value is thereforeThe supplied ${\varphi }_{12}(17)\approx 0.1$ also shows that the observed count does not enter the approximate 10% upper-tail rejection region. Thus there is insufficient evidence to reject $\mu =1$ at either the 10% or 5% level. The question specifies no testing level, so the p-value gives the general conclusion: rejection is justified only at levels at least about $0.1556$.

The printed ${\varphi }_1(16)\approx 0$ concerns a Poisson variable with mean one, not the twelve-month total. It is therefore not the null tail for this data; substituting it would incorrectly treat the yearly count as one month's count.