Past exam of the quantum condensed matter course of the University of Cambridge / 2009 / Section A / A1 / b / Solution

For a spherical micelle with $N$ tails, core radius $r$, molecular tail volume $v$ and head-group area $a$, volume and surface counting give $Nv=4\pi r^3/3$ and $Na=4\pi r^2$. Consequently $a=3v/r$. A tail cannot span a core radius larger than its maximum length $\ell$, so the amphiphile packing parameter condition isThis is a minimum area, not a maximum. The printed request reverses the geometric inequality. The limiting value corresponds to fully extended tails with $r=\ell$; larger head groups permit smaller spherical aggregates in this simple packing argument. The supplied data alone impose no finite maximum head-group area, and geometry alone does not guarantee thermodynamic micelle formation.