Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2007 iii Paper 37 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Let be the set of three-vertex subsets and let indicate that forms a triangle. ThenIn particular . We will use the Stein-Chen method with edge-sharing dependency neighborhoods, rather than wrongly treating triangle indicators as mutually independent.
Here is the needed Poisson approximation with dependency neighborhoods, together with its proof. For indicators with means , let contain and suppose is independent of the entire family of indicators outside . With and , defineThe total variation distance convention is . We claimFor an indicator test function on the nonnegative integers, solve the Poisson Stein equationwith . This elementary Stein factor can be proved as follows. Take the immigration--death process with immigration rate and per-particle death rate one. Starting at , its time- distribution iswith independent summands. Its stationary law is that of . Coupling the initial particles with a stationary Poisson initial population makes the centered expectations decay at least as a constant times , sois finite. Its generator equation is , obtained by integrating the semigroup derivative. Set for ; choose , which does not affect the equation. To bound , couple the processes starting at by adding two independent initial particles. Both survive to time with probability , and otherwise their second difference cancels in expectation. Since ,This proves the Stein factor for , and the chosen handles .
Put . Independence gives . Inserting this identity into the Stein equation yieldsThe first sum in absolute value is at most , since the two arguments differ by . In the second sum, on the arguments differ by , giving bound . Taking the supremum over event indicators proves the claimed total variation distance bound.
For triangle , choose to consist of itself and all triangles sharing an edge with . There are exactly such triangles. Every outside triangle uses none of the three edges of , even if it shares one vertex, so is independent of their entire indicator family. For distinct neighboring triangles, their union has five edges and . ThereforeThe Stein-Chen method gives . Coupling Poisson distributions of two means by adding an independent Poisson variable givesThis proves the Poisson limit for triangles in a binomial random graph:Applying the same bound to the event givesFor finite this is an approximation, not an exact formula: the error from is at most , and the error from is at most .
If , the triangle count in a binomial random graph has expectation at most , so the Markov inequality shows there are no triangles in a graph with probability tending to one. If , the triangle variance in a binomial random graph divided by the squared mean is . The second moment method then gives at least one triangle in a graph with probability tending to one. At the intermediate scale , a nontrivial Poisson limit for triangles in a binomial random graph describes the count.