Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2017 1 b Solution 2026-10-25
For , let be the indicator function of . In the ring of functions , multiplication is pointwise, soSuppose first that is finite, and let be an ideal of . Define . If , choose such an ; multiplying it by shows that . Every satisfieswhere the real scalars are constant functions. Thus has a finite generating set of an ideal, so is a Noetherian ring. If is empty, is the zero ring, and the conclusion still holds.
If is infinite, consider the idealIt is an ideal because a sum has support contained in the union of the two supports, and multiplication by any function cannot enlarge support. If generated , their supports would have a finite union . Every element of would vanish outside , whereas for any . This contradiction proves
Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2017 2 d Solution 2026-10-25
No. A domain with a nonzero idempotent maximal ideal is a counterexample. ConsiderThis can be realized concretely as a ring of functions on : its elements are finite sums of rational multiples of nonnegative dyadic rational powers of . Each stage is a polynomial ring, because a nonzero polynomial cannot vanish for all . Any two elements lie in one stage, which is an integral domain, so their product is nonzero if both are nonzero. Thus is an integral domain.
The constant term defines a surjective ring homomorphism . It is well defined because replacing by preserves the constant term. Its kernel of a ring homomorphismis a maximal ideal, since is a field, by the maximal ideal quotient criterion. Also is nonzero.
If , choose a stage in which for a polynomial . ThenBoth factors belong to , so . The reverse inclusion holds for every ideal, proving that is an idempotent ideal. HenceThe Noetherian ring hypothesis in c is therefore essential even for a maximal ideal.