Decay amplitude 2026-10-14
The invariant decay amplitude is the transition matrix element for one incoming particle and a specified on-shell final state, with the overall momentum delta function factored out. For covariantly normalized states, write the connected S-matrix element as . Its overall phase does not affect the decay width. The rate is , with the initial spin average included when the initial state is unpolarized. For a spin-zero parent and an angle-independent two-body amplitude, the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space gives . In leptonic pion decay, contracting the axial hadronic matrix element with the chiral weak charged current makes this amplitude proportional to the charged-lepton mass, proving helicity suppression.
For , the on-shell longitudinal pair contributes the displayed tree-level partial decay width. In the Higgs boson rest frame, its polarization vectors have contraction . Multiplying by the Higgs boson coupling to W bosons gives ; the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space then gives the width. The sum over transverse polarizations adds to the longitudinal polynomial. Below threshold, physical decays through virtual W bosons require a different multiparticle calculation.
For the current with rather than , the spin-summed symmetric leptonic tensor is . Integrating the standard two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space of two massless particles gives
Its antisymmetric Levi-Civita symbol term integrates to zero. The normalization changes by a factor of four if the current uses instead. The result separates the leptonic integration from hadronic pseudoscalar-to-pseudoscalar form factors in a three-body decay rate.
In the convention , the Fermi interaction gives . With a massless antineutrino, the external Dirac equations reduce this to . The spin sum is . The two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space has integrated value , and the initial flux factor is , giving the displayed width. If the decay constant is instead defined without the square root of two, and the denominator is . A weak mixing coefficient multiplies the amplitude and its modulus squared multiplies the width.
For the Z boson vertex , sum over the three initial polarizations and final fermion spins. The symmetric Dirac trace is . The vector-axial interference is antisymmetric and drops out of the massive vector polarization sum. The longitudinal term drops out by current conservation for massless final particles. Contracting the remaining trace gives the displayed result. The massive-vector spin average divides it by three; two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space then gives per color. These coefficients are twice those used with a vertex prefactor .
The chiral weak charged current vertex gives the spin-averaged squared matrix element for an on-shell W boson decaying to a massless charged lepton and antineutrino. Integrating two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space gives . The massive-vector spin average divides by three; an extra neutrino-helicity factor would incorrectly double count the chiral projector.
Massless leptonic Z decay width Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-18
For a vertex into one massless color-singlet particle-antiparticle pair, the massive-vector spin average and two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space give . With Standard Model neutral-current vector and axial couplings, one neutrino flavor has and one charged-lepton flavor has . Chiral projectors already remove inactive neutrino helicities. These are tree-level massless results.
Massless neutrino-electron contact cross-section Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-14
For a left-handed incoming neutrino, unpolarized electrons, and electron vector/axial couplings , the four-fermion interaction gives . Integrating massless two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space yields . The electron spin average is included, while no sterile neutrino helicity is averaged in.
Use natural units and the Minkowski metric . Varying the Proca action with respect to gives and . The Euler-Lagrange equation is therefore
Taking a divergence annihilates the antisymmetric field strength, since commuting derivatives are symmetric in their indices. For this gives the Lorenz constraint in Proca theory , and hence . The constraint follows from dynamics; it is not an additional gauge fixing condition for this massive theory.
For four-momentum , longitudinal polarization of a massive vector boson lies in the time– plane, has and is normalized by . Taking
satisfies both requirements because . It can also be obtained by boosting the rest-frame unit spatial polarization along the direction of motion. Together with two transverse polarizations it gives the three physical spin states of a massive spin one particle.
In the Higgs boson rest frame, choose and , with and . Consistent normalized longitudinal polarization vectors are
Their Lorentz contraction is . The Higgs boson coupling to W bosons consequently gives
Using the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space, and yields the longitudinal partial decay width
The charged W bosons are distinguishable, so there is no identical-particle factor of . This expression includes the entire angular phase space but only the specified longitudinal final polarizations. The Higgs decay to two W bosons summed over all polarizations instead has the factor ; the additional transverse contribution is . At the longitudinal channel dominates and the leading width grows as .
Figure 1.
On-shell Higgs decay: longitudinal and transverse contributions to the W-pair width
. Details.
The Standard Model is a chiral gauge theory: left-chiral quarks and leptons form SU(2) weak doublets, while the corresponding right-chiral charged fields are weak singlets. The covariant kinetic term contains . With , its off-diagonal generators give the weak charged current
An overall interaction sign depends on the convention for the covariant derivative and has no effect on this decay rate. The chiral projector explains the vector-minus-axial combination. The Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix comes from the different left-handed rotations that diagonalize up- and down-type fermion mass matrices. Set and as stipulated.
Let , the massive vector polarization sum. Sum over final spins and average over the two equally populated initial top quark spins. The fermion spin sum and the Dirac adjoint of the vertex give
The term vanishes because . Anticommuting through the remaining gamma matrices, using , then using cyclicity of the matrix trace and the symmetry of yields
The extra factor two from the chiral algebra compensates the initial spin-average factor. The term with is antisymmetric in and vanishes upon contraction with . The remaining gamma-matrix trace is
Its contraction gives
Here , , and , so
Therefore
The two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space has rest-frame momentum . Substitution into gives the two-body top-quark decay width
The squared threshold factor combines the vanishing final momentum with the corresponding kinematic factor in the squared scattering amplitude. The longitudinal W boson polarization contributes the high-mass enhancement proportional to . The result is at tree level, for an on-shell W boson and ; finite bottom mass and radiative corrections change it. Restoring quark mixing multiplies the width by .
Use the current convention in the question, whose vertex prefactor is . The neutral-current vector and axial couplings are then
For a charged lepton, , , giving
For an active neutrino, , , so . The right-handed weak singlet contribution is purely vectorlike in the charge term; combining it with the left-handed contribution gives precisely this Dirac-current form. These coefficients would be halved if the vertex prefactor were instead.
Let be the Z boson momentum and the outgoing massless lepton momenta. The decay amplitude is
Use the fermion spin sums and . Anticommutation of with the Dirac gamma matrices gives the symmetric part of the trace,
The vector-axial cross term is antisymmetric in , and hence drops out of the massive vector polarization sum. The massless equations also give : in the symmetric part, the first two contractions sum to , canceling the last; the antisymmetric term vanishes because . The longitudinal term therefore makes no contribution.
Since , contraction with gives . Thus the massless fermion Z decay spin sum, including all three initial polarizations, is
To use this fully summed expression for the decay width of one unpolarized Z boson, apply the massive-vector spin average, dividing by three. The width of each fixed polarization is the same after integration over all directions, so that procedure also gives the physical single-particle width. Omitting the division would sum the widths of three initial states.
For two massless distinguishable final particles, the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space is
Consequently
The tree-level electroweak symmetry breaking relation is . Combining it with the Fermi constant normalization gives
For an active neutrino, the vertex itself projects out inactive chiralities, so no additional helicity factor is needed. This is the tree-level massless leptonic Z decay width; lepton masses and radiative corrections have been excluded.
Take metric and write . The outgoing electron and antineutrino momenta are and . Up to an irrelevant overall phase, the amplitude is
A fermion spin sum gives
Anticommuting through the massless momentum and gamma matrix, and using , reduces the trace to twice the four-gamma trace minus twice its counterpart. In particular its symmetric part is
The epsilon-tensor part is antisymmetric and contributes neither to the unpolarized polarization sum nor to the real linear polarization used below. There is no extra factor for selecting the neutrino helicity: the chiral vertex has already done so.
The external massless equations imply for , so . With , averaging over the three initial spin states gives
Indeed . This is a massive-vector spin average, not an average over the final spins.
In the rest frame, eliminating the momentum delta function and integrating the remaining radial delta function reduces the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space to . Therefore
This derives the massless leptonic W decay width without invoking a precomputed decay formula.
For the specified polarization there is no initial spin average. Put , and . The contraction selects
It follows that
Here . The total rate agrees with the spin-averaged result, but its normalized polar distribution is instead of the isotropic unpolarized distribution. This is polarized massless leptonic W decay.
Use the source convention , with electric charge measured in units of the positron charge. Expanding the covariant derivative in the fermion kinetic term gives interaction . Substituting the given neutral-field rotation, the coefficient of is
The photon coefficient is , with . For a Dirac field, acts only on its left-handed component. Thus
The weak neutral current interaction consequently has the requested form, with
The electroweak representation and hypercharge table gives the following values for one generation:
Type on left
Neutrinoabsent
Charged lepton
Up-type quark
Down-type quark
These neutral-current vector and axial couplings use the source's vertex prefactor . They are twice the coefficients used with prefactor ; the latter convention must not be mixed into this calculation. For the neutrino, the chiral projector removes the inactive right-handed component automatically.
Set and suppress the species label. For outgoing momenta , the amplitude is, up to an irrelevant phase,
The final-state spin sum is the Dirac trace of . Anticommutation of with the gamma matrices makes its symmetric part
The vector-axial cross term is proportional to the antisymmetric Levi-Civita symbol, so it contracts to zero with the symmetric massive vector polarization sum . Since , the symmetric tensor is transverse to as well. Only remains, and
Multiplying by proves the massless fermion Z decay spin sum:
For the decay width, average over the three initial polarizations. Rotational invariance makes the integrated width the same for each initial spin state, so the massive-vector spin average is legitimate even for a single prepared polarization. In the rest frame, the delta functions in two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space leave
This follows by setting and integrating ; the radial integration supplies a factor . Hence
For a quark species multiply by three colors, with strong-interaction radiative corrections when comparing with data. For one effectively massless active neutrino, , so .
The total resonance width contains visible charged-lepton and hadron decays plus . Thus the measured invisible contribution determines
Early resonance measurements supported three light active neutrino species, with experimental uncertainties; the OPAL analysis of its 1989 data explicitly compares the three- and four-species predictions. Under the question's assumption that every possible family has a massless neutrino with ordinary weak couplings, this constrains the number of such families. The inference does not exclude additional neutrinos heavier than or gauge singlet sterile states with no ordinary coupling. This is light-neutrino counting from the Z width.
Put and neglect electron and final-quark masses compared with . First fix a final color charge; its multiplicity will be restored for the inclusive rate. The photon-exchange scattering amplitude is, up to an overall phase,
Averaging over the two spins of each incident particle and summing final spins gives
By the gamma matrix trace identities, the first trace is , and likewise for the second. Contracting the two tensors cancels the terms proportional to , giving
In the centre-of-mass frame all four energies are . The first pair of scalar products equals each, and the second pair equals each. Hence .
For clarity, the printed flux hint has a factor-of-four inconsistency: when , the prefactor multiplying the spin-averaged amplitude is , not . Alternatively, is correct if . Use this massless two-body scattering flux normalization, keeping the spin average separate.
To obtain the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space directly, integrate the momentum-conserving spatial delta function, leaving . The remaining radial integral is , so . The relativistic scattering cross-section is consequently
Since , the integrated electron-positron annihilation into a quark pair result, for this fixed color, is
The first two printed formulas are thus color-stripped. Distinct final colors are orthogonal states and must be summed, producing . At leading order each accessible quark flavor contributes independently. Away from thresholds and narrow resonances, quark-hadron duality relates the inclusive parton rate to the observed inclusive electron-positron annihilation into hadrons, giving
This formula concerns the photon channel, assumes is large compared with the relevant quark masses and the strong-interaction scale, and does not include Z boson exchange.
Beyond leading order, an exactly exclusive pair of colored quarks is not an observable asymptotic state because of confinement and hadronization. Moreover its virtual corrections have infrared divergences; real soft or collinear gluon emission cannot be excluded if a finite rate is wanted. The inclusive sum includes both the corrected two-parton channel and channels such as , with their degenerate soft and collinear limits. Real and virtual infrared divergences then cancel for an infrared-safe observable. A specified jet observable can also be meaningful if it defines an infrared-safe observable; a bare two-quark final state is not.
A convenient inclusive calculation uses the optical theorem. For the electromagnetic hadronic current , define
The hadronic electromagnetic-current spectral density is obtained from its discontinuity. In this convention the hadronic R ratio is , where at this order. Cutting the forward amplitude sums all allowed hadronic intermediate states, so perturbative Quantum chromodynamics applied to this inclusive quantity implements the required sum of real and virtual contributions.
Finally, write , , , and . The given truncated correction is
Differentiate with respect to , using the stated one-loop beta function and . The derivative of cancels the explicit logarithmic derivative at order . Keeping the residual derivative of the truncated expression gives
Thus the principle of minimal sensitivity, applied to this expression with nonzero coupling and , selects the one-loop stationary scale for the hadronic annihilation correction
This is a prescription based on the residual order- scale dependence of an order- approximation. At strictly order , the derivative already vanishes for every renormalization scale; the prescription does not assert exact scale dependence of the observable. It is useful only while the selected running coupling remains perturbative. If or , the stated derivative imposes no unique scale.
At momentum transfers small compared with , the two weak charged current vertices each carry when written with , and the W boson propagator reduces to a local factor proportional to . Matching their product to the Fermi interaction gives, at tree level,
The Fermi constant is thus determined by the electroweak coupling and symmetry-breaking scale; the four-fermion description is a low-energy effective interaction.
Only the cross term can annihilate the pion and create the stated charged-lepton/antineutrino pair. Its leptonic matrix element is . Lorentz covariance permits a vacuum-to-spin-zero current matrix element only proportional to . At rest this has only a temporal component. The vacuum is parity-even and the pion is parity-odd, while is parity-even, so equals its own negative and vanishes. Lorentz covariance then makes the full vector matrix element vanish. The temporal axial current is parity-odd and is allowed: this is the vacuum-to-pseudoscalar current selection rule.
The minus sign in cancels the interaction's minus sign, up to an irrelevant common S-matrix phase. Therefore
The pion decay constant convention here includes the given in its current matrix element. Momentum conservation and the external Dirac equations give , , . Since , the neutrino term vanishes and
This is helicity suppression: the amplitude vanishes in the zero charged-lepton-mass limit despite the larger available phase space.
For the spin sum, the Dirac adjoint of is , and the completeness relations give
The chiral projectors automatically eliminate the unused neutrino helicity when the full massless completeness relation is inserted. There is no initial spin average for a spin-zero pion.
In the pion rest frame, let , . After integrating the spatial delta function and angles, the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space becomes
The root is and . The absolute derivative of the delta-function argument is . Thus . Multiplying by the spin sum and the initial factor yields the leptonic pseudoscalar decay width
If the decay constant were instead defined by a matrix element without , then and the width coefficient would be ; mixing these conventions would introduce a factor-of-two error.
The same derivation for a muon cancels the common hadronic and weak factors in the pion electron-to-muon decay ratio:
The numerical value uses approximate masses MeV. Agreement with the corresponding Standard Model prediction tests lepton universality and the chiral, helicity-suppressing structure of the weak charged current, rather than the poorly calculable hadronic decay constant. A difference in the electron and muon weak couplings would multiply the ratio by their squared coupling ratio. Precision agreement must be assessed after radiative corrections, with matching photon-inclusive experimental definitions; the displayed tree-level ratio is not itself the radiatively corrected precision prediction.
Use metric signature and average over the four initial spin states, summing over final spins and the quark color charge states. The electrons carry no color charge, so their initial color charge average is trivial. A final color charge average would not give the inclusive relativistic cross-section requested.
Photon exchange gives the tree amplitude, up to an irrelevant overall phase,
Massless spin sums give and . Therefore
The color charge multiplicity is , not . Each trace equals . Contracting them, the terms proportional to cancel, leaving . Thus
In the centre-of-momentum frame every energy is . Let be the angle between and . Then
Consequently .
The supplied two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space formula has a factor-of-two error. Deriving the normalization explicitly,
so the massless two-body scattering flux normalization is
For example, integrating the spatial Dirac delta in leaves ; its radial integral supplies the factor . The printed denominator would double the relativistic cross-section and cannot reproduce the requested result with the standard scattering amplitude.
The correctly normalized differential and total results for electron-positron annihilation into a quark pair are
and hence
At energies where photon exchange and the parton description apply, sum over kinematically accessible quark flavors. The produced quarks undergo hadronization, so the leading inclusive hadronic rate is
This is the hadronic R ratio. Perturbative QCD adds a leading relative correction ; thresholds, narrow resonances and, near the Z boson scale, electroweak exchange require additional treatment. The calculation is a photon-exchange, massless result from a tree-level Feynman diagram.
The middle panel shows the Feynman diagram for the leptonic W boson decay. With the charged-current Lagrangian density sign in the question, its vertex Feynman rule is
An overall field-phase convention can change the overall amplitude sign but cannot change the decay width. With the standard Dirac field current ordering, the amplitude is
The unusual order of barred fields in the printed description should be interpreted as this physical weak charged current matrix element.
For massless final fermions, the fermion spin sums are and . The massive-vector spin average divides by three. Thus
with the chiral trace
Anticommuting through the two following gamma matrices and using gives its symmetric part
Its remaining part is an antisymmetric epsilon tensor from the gamma matrix trace identities; it vanishes against the symmetric polarization tensor . Direct contraction gives and
Hence
No additional averaging over hypothetical right-handed neutrino states is appropriate: the chiral projector already enforces the physical helicity coupling.
On shell, , and , so and . The squared matrix element reduces to . In the parent rest frame, integrate the spatial momentum delta first in two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space. The remaining radial integral is
Consequently the massless leptonic W decay width is
Lepton universality gives in the same massless approximation. The muon and tau lepton masses produce small corrections if retained.
With an identity CKM matrix, the allowed quark channels are and . The corresponding third-generation channel is closed by the top threshold. Each open channel has three orthogonal matching-color final states, so the color multiplicity in a decay width gives . There is no initial color average because the W boson is colorless. The tree-level W branching fractions are therefore:
Final channelPartial widthBranching fraction, rounded
The rounded percentages sum to 99% because of rounding. The exact fractions sum to one, with total leptonic fraction and hadronic fraction . The total decay width is
As an illustrative numerical estimate, taking and gives , each open quark width and . These are tree-level model estimates with the stated illustrative inputs, not a fit to a measured width. Strong radiative corrections increase the inclusive quark widths.
The produced quark and antiquark radiate gluons, generating a parton shower. As their virtualities fall towards the strong-interaction scale, perturbation theory gives way to hadronization: confinement converts the colored partons into color-neutral hadrons, typically seen as two particle jets, with additional radiation sometimes producing resolved extra jets. Unstable hadrons subsequently decay; the primary quarks are not observed as free particles.
Including the CKM matrix, the charged current couples an accessible up-type flavour to every kinematically accessible down-type flavour . Therefore
The sums over remain by row unitarity, so the massless tree-level total remains . Quark mixing redistributes the hadronic branching fractions; it does not create a new total color factor. If a family is above threshold, only its accessible channels enter, and the unitarity sum must not be applied to an incomplete set of final flavours.
For completeness, CKM parameter counting starts with real degrees of freedom of an unitary matrix. This follows by counting real entries and independent Hermitian constraints in . The real-orthogonal subclass has mixing angles; the remaining parameters can be viewed as phases. Rephasing each up-type and down-type mass eigenfield changes by . Of the phases, the common phase does nothing, so are removable. Thus
For three generic nondegenerate families this is three angles and one CP-violating phase. Degenerate masses can allow additional changes of basis and reduce the count.
The product of leptonic weak charged currents in the Fermi interaction contains four-fermion cross terms such as
This produces , and the same interaction permits neutrino-electron scattering and inverse muon decay. Pure electromagnetic interactions have no neutrino coupling and preserve the separate charged-lepton species, so cannot produce these processes by themselves. The factor fixes the chiral structure of the weak charged current.
The pion is a pseudoscalar with negative parity, while the strong-interaction vacuum is parity even. Lorentz covariance restricts a vacuum-to-pion vector-current matrix element to . In the pion rest frame only its temporal component could be nonzero, but a vector current's temporal component is parity even, whereas the pion is parity odd. The matrix element therefore equals its negative and vanishes. The temporal component of an axial current is parity odd, so its matrix element is allowed and Lorentz covariance fixes it to a constant times . Defining the pion decay constant in the printed normalization gives
This proves both the vector-current exclusion and the axial-current form; itself is a strong-interaction parameter, not fixed by symmetry.
The cross term gives, up to an irrelevant overall phase, the decay amplitude
Take the antineutrino mass to be zero. Since , , and , anticommutation with gives
The amplitude has helicity suppression by one power of the charged-lepton mass.
Using the external spin sums, with no initial spin average for a spin-zero pion,
The middle equality follows from , , and the gamma matrix trace identities. Summing a full massless neutrino spin basis introduces no factor of two: the current projector annihilates the inactive helicity.
For completeness, evaluate the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space in the pion rest frame. Its three-momentum delta function sets , and the energy delta function is . The radial root is
Combining its derivative with and integrating solid angle gives
The invariant squared amplitude is independent of direction, so the supplied decay formula yields the leptonic pseudoscalar decay width
The denominator is because the matrix element contains . With the alternative definition , the same width is . In either convention it vanishes as .
Replacing the electron by a muon gives the same hadronic factor and weak coupling. Hence the pion electron-to-muon decay ratio is
This is a tree-level result with massless neutrinos. The cancellation of and makes the ratio a clean test of the predicted helicity suppression and electron–muon universality in the chiral weak charged current. For example, scalar or pseudoscalar four-fermion interactions could remove the charged-lepton mass factor and substantially enhance the electron mode. Radiative corrections are required for a precision experimental comparison.
With two quark generations, the charged hadronic current contains
A contains , so its annihilation into the lepton pair selects the term proportional to . Strong strangeness conservation excludes the term from its vacuum matrix element. Its amplitude is thus multiplied by and its width by :
Here is the pure strong-interaction decay constant in the same square-root-of-two convention. If the pion current's quark mixing coefficient is also shown explicitly, its width carries ; it is already absorbed if the stated pion matrix element uses the full weak current. Thus the isolated weak-factor ratio is , while the kaon suppression relative to unit weak coupling is the requested Cabibbo suppression factor .
Put and . The left-handed doublet has
while the right-handed charged-lepton singlet has and . There is no weakly coupled right-handed neutrino in the stated field content. For a fermion , write and , with here. Since and similarly for ,
Consequently the neutral-current vector and axial couplings in the specified overall normalization are
These coefficients accompany . A convention with uses twice these vector and axial coefficients; mixing the two conventions would make the widths wrong by a factor of four. For the neutrino, , so the chiral projection is already built into the vertex.
For either massless final pair with momenta , , the invariant amplitude is, up to an irrelevant overall phase,
The spin-summed fermion tensor is
The symmetric part, using the four-gamma trace, is
The vector-axial interference is antisymmetric in , so it drops out of the symmetric polarization sum. Also for massless external fermions, by their Dirac equations; hence the part contributes zero. Using gives
The massive-vector spin average supplies the factor for the three spin states of the massive . The massless two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space is , and so . The spin-averaged amplitude above is angle-independent in the rest frame, giving
The massless leptonic Z decay widths for one charged-lepton flavor and one active neutrino flavor respectively are
There is no color factor for leptons and no extra final-state identical-particle factor for a particle-antiparticle pair. The neutrino projectors already exclude sterile helicity states, so no additional factor of two is needed. These are tree-level massless widths; electroweak radiative corrections and charged-lepton masses have not been included. If desired, using and converts the common prefactor to .
Let , neglect , and average over the two spin states of each incoming particle. Only the single-photon channel is being considered. The spectral-density symbol is not defined in the question, so specify its normalization before calculating. A useful photon-field convention is
Here is the product of final-particle measures , including the appropriate sums and symmetry factors. Lorentz invariance and current conservation give the transverse tensor form. In this convention is the hadronic photon spectral density, with mass dimension , rather than a density of a stationary time series.
The electron annihilation amplitude can be written , up to an overall phase. The leptonic tensor after the initial spin average is
It obeys and . In the center-of-momentum frame, the flux denominator in the hint is , since the relative speed is 2 and each beam energy is . Contracting the tensors gives the inclusive relativistic cross-section
Here is the fine-structure constant. The in the initial spin average is essential because the hint's particles were spinless.
For the other common convention, define the hadronic electromagnetic current with the coupling omitted, , and write its inclusive tensor as
Equivalently, for , one has . At leading order in the electromagnetic interaction, is proportional to . Thus
If the symbol is instead used for this dimensionless hadronic electromagnetic-current spectral density, the last formula applies with renamed . The normalization must not be silently switched between these formulas.
At well above the strong-coupling scale of Quantum chromodynamics, asymptotic freedom makes production over distances of order perturbative. The electromagnetic current initially creates a quark-antiquark pair. Subsequent strong interactions produce hadrons, but an inclusive sum over all hadronic final states is much less sensitive to this rearrangement than an exclusive channel. This is the regime in which quark-hadron duality motivates a leading parton model calculation, with radiative and power-suppressed corrections. It is not a pointwise theorem at individual resonances or near thresholds; the comparison is most reliable for sufficiently inclusive or suitably averaged high-energy observables. This argument remains restricted to photon exchange, even where additional electroweak channels could also contribute.
For one active massless quark flavor with charge , the tree-level scattering amplitude is
The two gamma-matrix traces, the initial spin average, and the final color charge sum yield
where and . The massless two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space then gives
Summing the distinct final flavors, rather than interfering amplitudes for them, gives
According to the permitted approximation in the paper, active flavors satisfy and are treated as massless; the others are omitted. This is the stipulated step approximation, not the exact pair-production threshold .
The hadronic R ratio is , relative to the massless muon-pair relativistic cross-section . If and active flavors have charges and , respectively,
For , the usual sets of three, four, five and six active flavors give . In the two spectral conventions the same leading calculation gives