Past exam of the quantum field theory course of the University of Oxford 2024 3 d Solution 2026-10-25
Set the renormalized to zero. For a six-scalar vertex, b gives , so a new overall logarithmic divergence can only occur in graphs with . With , the line counts become and , hence .
At one loop this forces and : the only candidate is a closed triangle Feynman diagram with two external scalar legs at each vertex. Its numerator at large loop momentum is proportional toThis vanishes for the specified two-component gamma matrices, each of which is traceless. Replacing one leading by the fermion mass or an external momentum lowers the superficial degree of divergence from zero to at most . Thus the apparent logarithm cancels. Graphs with a vertex already have negative overall degree; the pure-scalar one-loop triangle, for instance, has . There is no one-loop ultraviolet subdivergence inside these proper one-loop vertices. ThereforeThe six-point correlation function need not vanish: finite terms are allowed. Nor is it correct to say that all odd gamma-matrix traces vanish in dimensions. In this representation,The cancellation above follows from repeating the same leading loop momentum, not from a false four-dimensional trace rule.
At two loops, , and are possible. A closed fermion box with a scalar line joining two of its vertices leaves six external scalar legs. It has , , and four leading gamma matrices; the one-loop odd-numerator argument no longer applies.
A background-field check demonstrates that its logarithm is actually nonzero. Put with constant . Define the background fermion mass , the background scalar squared mass , and the induced three-leg Yukawa coupling . The two-loop quantum effective potential contains the sunset diagram with two fermion lines and one scalar line. After a Wick rotation, its relevant integral, apart from a nonzero overall combinatorial factor, isHere the dots and gamma-matrix traces are Euclidean. With , , , its numerator is exactlyThe first three terms reduce to products of one-loop tadpole integrals, which have no logarithmic pole near three dimensions in dimensional regularization. The remaining term isFor positive regulator masses, the large-momentum region of has a positive, nonzero logarithmic divergence. One can see this directly by restricting the relative angles and the ratio to compact intervals away from zero: the remaining common radial integral is proportional to . Its proper one-loop subgraphs are ultraviolet convergent.
Finally, the coefficient multiplying containsThe two-loop sextic counterterm in quartic Yukawa theory follows because its coefficient is for a nonzero coupling. Other two-loop vacuum topologies reduce to products of finite-in-dimensional-regularization tadpoles and do not cancel this logarithmic pole. ThusA sextic counterterm is required even if the renormalized sextic coupling is set to zero at a chosen renormalization scale. A theory constrained to at every scale lacks counterterm closure when . The decoupled exception is the three-dimensional scalar quartic interaction, which needs no sextic counterterm by power counting.