 Solution

The linear independence of the first $n$ elements of each orthonormal system shows that $T_n$ and $S_n$ have the same finite dimension $n$ and are closed subspaces of a Hilbert space. Apply part (b) with $U=T_n$ and $V=S_n^{\perp }$. Since $(S_n^{\perp }{)}^{\perp }=S_n$, the positive directed subspace angle cosine givesLet $Q$ be the oblique projection onto $T_n$ along $S_n^{\perp }$. Define ${\tilde{f}}_n=Qf$. Its residual $f-Qf$ is orthogonal to every ${\psi }_j$ with $1\le j\le n$, so the required measurements agree. Conversely, if $g\in T_n$ has the same measurements, then $f-g\in S_n^{\perp }$; uniqueness of the direct sum decomposition gives $g=Qf$. Thus this is finite-dimensional Hilbert sampling reconstruction.

There is also an explicit coefficient description. Use the inner product convention linear in its first entry and putThen $Cc=b$. The orthonormal systems show $\Vert P_{S_n}{\sum }_k{c}_k{\varphi }_k\Vert =\Vert Cc{\Vert }_2$ and $\Vert {\sum }_k{c}_k{\varphi }_k\Vert =\Vert c{\Vert }_2$, so the smallest singular value of $C$ is $\cos {\theta }_{T_n,S_n}>0$. Hence $c=C^{-1}b$, another direct proof of existence and uniqueness.

For $n\ge 1$, both summands of this direct sum are nonzero: the infinite orthonormal system $({\psi }_j)$ contains ${\psi }_{n+1}\in S_n^{\perp }$. The permitted oblique projection norm formula therefore applies without its degenerate exception, givingThe operator norm immediately yields the stability estimate $\Vert {\tilde{f}}_n\Vert \le \sec {\theta }_{T_n,S_n}\Vert f\Vert$. For the approximation bounds, put $e=f-P_{T_n}f$. Because $Q$ fixes $T_n$, we haveso the operator norm estimate gives $\Vert f-Qf\Vert \le \sec {\theta }_{T_n,S_n}\Vert e\Vert$. For the lower bound, $e\perp T_n$ while $P_{T_n}f-Qf\in T_n$. The Pythagorean identity givesThe unique measurement-matching reconstruction is stable and within the secant function factor of the best orthogonal projection approximation:If a zero-dimensional reconstruction is admitted, it is simply ${\tilde{f}}_0=0$ and its error equals the norm of $f$; that case is best stated directly instead of using the angle of a zero space.