 b

Assume the cylinders are released from rest. In each case, “there is friction” is interpreted as sufficient static friction for rolling without slipping at the rough contacts. Without a coefficient or a no-slip assumption, sliding cases would not have a unique specified acceleration. On release the two lower cylinders separate; their mutual contact must not be retained as a rigid constraint.

Let the top cylinder's initial downward acceleration be $w$, and each lower cylinder's outward horizontal acceleration be $u$. The top cylinder initially has no horizontal acceleration. Differentiating the fixed upper-to-lower centre separation twice at the initial zero velocity givesBy reflection symmetry the top cylinder has zero angular acceleration, while the lower cylinders rotate in opposite senses.