Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-short-options-paper-shared-by-prelims-and-parts-a-and-b-of-the-physics-course-of-the-university-of-oxford/2018/s18/3/b/solution

In two spatial dimensions there are only two kinetic matrices and one mass matrix. The three Pauli matrices square to identity and anticommute pairwise, so
is a two-component Dirac Hamiltonian with . It therefore reproduces the stated first-order equation and its Klein-Gordon square. Requiring a fourth anticommuting matrix in three spatial dimensions is precisely what prevented this two-component construction above.
Printed angular-momentum qualification. Define the dimensionless spin and the physical orbital angular momentum , with . Then
The source prints instead. Taken literally, it is anti-Hermitian, has incompatible units with the dimensionless spin when they are added, and gives
It cannot yield the requested usual angular-momentum algebra or conservation law. For a concrete counterexample set and take a wave with momentum along . Since
the printed obeys .
The physically consistent operator is . It satisfies
The cancellation follows directly from the two mixed commutators above. In a spherical basis the free spinor can be labelled by energy, , and , together with a parity or equivalent Dirac angular label distinguishing the two orbital couplings . Alternatively one can choose a momentum and helicity basis. One cannot simultaneously assign all components of momentum and all angular labels as independent commuting observables.

New to topics? Read the docs here!