Position-momentum selection rules in the first excited hydrogen eigenspace

ID: position-momentum-selection-rules-in-the-first-excited-hydrogen-eigenspace

Both and commute with and are odd under parity. Their angular selection rules therefore require the same magnetic quantum number and opposite orbital parity. Within the nonrelativistic point-Coulomb hydrogen atom eigenspace, the only angularly permitted off-diagonal pair is and .
Those necessary angular conditions do not guarantee a nonzero matrix element. For the Coulomb potential Hamiltonian ,
All states within this exact eigenspace have the same energy, so every projected matrix element vanishes. In contrast, the position matrix element is nonzero: with conventional real spherical harmonics and hydrogen radial wavefunction in the first excited shell, . Its sign depends on basis phases, while its magnitude does not.
Thus the electric-dipole selection rules for hydrogen allow a linear position perturbation to mix these degenerate states, but a momentum perturbation cannot be assigned the same matrix merely from parity. The conclusion concerns the unperturbed Coulomb eigenspace; degeneracy-breaking interactions require their own energy eigenstates and matrix elements.

New to topics? Read the docs here!