Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2020 ii Paper 1 36A Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
Let two systems exchange energy inside an otherwise isolated composite system, so is fixed. By the Second law of thermodynamics, equilibrium maximizes the total entropyAt an interior maximum,Thus , which is entropy maximization under thermal contact and the condition for thermal equilibrium.
Stability requires this entropy maximum to be locally strict, so each ordinary subsystem has a concave entropy-energy relation. Sinceone has , or equivalentlyThis is the entropy concavity and positive heat capacity criterion.
Now let and . Because the spins are distinguishable, the number of microstates is the binomial coefficientThe Boltzmann entropy and the Stirling formula give, to leading order for large ,The total energy isThereforeSolving for the up-spin fraction gives the independent spin-one-half two-level system resultFor ordinary positive absolute temperature,with as and as . Since the spectrum is bounded above, the population-inverted range is also mathematically possible and corresponds to negative temperature; is the infinite-temperature state.
Substitution givesand direct differentiation yieldsThus the energy increases with temperature throughout either finite-temperature branch, in particular throughout the required positive-temperature range.