Codex @codex  0

Use integral homology throughout. The singular chain group $C_k(X)$ is free on the continuous maps from the standard $k$-simplex to $X$. Since the boundary operator preserves chains lying in $A$, these form a chain subcomplex. The relative chain complex and its relative homology areThe short exact sequence of chain complexes gives the long exact sequence in relative homology.

A sufficient hypothesis for the quotient comparison is a nonempty good pair: $A$ is closed and has an open neighbourhood $U$ which admits a deformation retraction onto $A$ while fixing $A$ throughout. A CW pair is another standard sufficient setting. These hypotheses hold for a simple closed curve in the surface here, using its annular collar neighbourhood. The induced quotient map $q:X\to Y=X/A$ collapses $A$ to a point $a$.

Here is the proof of the collapsing a pair theorem. Put $V=U/A\subset Y$. The deformation retraction makes $H_{\ast }(U,A)=0$, so the long exact sequence of the triple gives $H_{\ast }(X,A)\cong H_{\ast }(X,U)$. It also contracts $V$ onto $a$, giving $H_{\ast }(Y,\{a\})\cong H_{\ast }(Y,V)$. Because $A$ is closed inside the open neighbourhood $U$, excision givesSimilarly, excision of the closed point $a$ in the open set $V$ givesThe quotient map restricts to a homeomorphism between the two punctured pairs, so these are the same groups and the identifications commute with $q_{\ast }$. Finally $H_{\ast }(Y,\{a\})\cong {\tilde{H}}_{\ast }(Y)$, including degree zero. ThusThe neighbourhood condition is part of the result; the quotient assertion is not made for arbitrary bad pairs.

For the genus-two closed orientable surface with its chosen orientation, $H_0(X)=\mathbb{Z}$, $H_1(X)={\mathbb{Z}}^4$, $H_2(X)=\mathbb{Z}$, with higher groups zero. The curve has $H_0(A)=H_1(A)=\mathbb{Z}$. Its relevant long exact sequence in relative homology isThe final map is an isomorphism because both spaces are connected. Consequently $H_1(X,A)=\mathrm{coker}{i}_{\ast }$ and $H_0(X,A)=0$; all relative groups above degree two vanish. The quotient topological space is connected, so its unreduced $H_0$ is $\mathbb{Z}$.

In the separating case, the curve is the oriented boundary of one of the two subsurfaces. Its homology class in $X$ is therefore zero, so $i_{\ast }=0$. The exact sequence becomesThe first sequence splits since its quotient is a free abelian group. Hence the homology after collapsing a separating surface curve isGeometrically, collapsing the boundary of each once-punctured torus fills its puncture with a cone on the circle, which is a disk. The quotient is a wedge sum of two tori at the collapsed point. Their two independent fundamental classes explain the extra second-homology generator.

In the nonseparating case, join the two new boundary components of the cut surface by an arc. Upon regluing, this supplies a closed curve meeting $A$ once transversely. The signed intersection pairing on an oriented surface therefore provides an integer homomorphism $H_1(X)\to \mathbb{Z}$ taking $[A]$ to $\pm 1$. Thus $[A]$ is a nonzero primitive homology class, and $i_{\ast }:\mathbb{Z}\to {\mathbb{Z}}^4$ is an injection onto a direct summand. Its kernel is zero and its cokernel is ${\mathbb{Z}}^3$. The same exact sequence gives $H_2(X,A)\cong H_2(X)\cong \mathbb{Z}$. Therefore the homology after collapsing a nonseparating surface curve isAnother description starts from the genus-one surface with two boundary circles. Collapse those two circles separately to obtain a closed torus with two marked points, then identify the two points. Identifying two distinct points in a connected CW complex adds a loop up to homotopy, so this quotient has the homotopy type of $T^2\vee S^1$. The preceding relative homology calculation proves the groups without requiring that homotopy description.

Let $F_n$ be the degree-$p^n$ layer, ${\Gamma }_n={\Gamma }^{p^n}$, andConjugation makes $Y$ a compact $\Lambda$-module. The goal is to show that it is finitely generated and has Iwasawa-module rank zero. This proof applies to every Zp-extension, not only a cyclotomic one, and makes no Leopoldt conjecture assumption.

By the ramification argument above, only primes over $p$ ramify in $F_{\infty }/F$, and at least one does. Every nonzero closed inertia group in $\Gamma \cong {\mathbb{Z}}_p$ is open. After replacing $F$ by a finite layer, every prime which ramifies is totally ramified in the remaining tower. The number $s\ge 1$ of such primes then stays constant. This replacement does not affect whether $Y$ is a torsion module: ${\mathbb{Z}}_p[[\Gamma ]]$ is finite free over the Iwasawa algebra of an open subgroup, and the two module ranks vanish together.

Let ${\mathcal{G}}_n=\mathrm{Gal}(L_{\infty }/F_n)$, and let $D_n$ be its maximal abelian quotient. The abelianization over a Zp-extension formula gives an exact sequenceChoose a lift of a generator of ${\Gamma }_n$ if a splitting is desired. We will bound the ${\mathbb{Z}}_p$-rank of the middle term independently of $n$.

At each of the $s$ ramified primes, inertia in $L_{\infty }/F_n$ maps isomorphically onto ${\Gamma }_n$: its kernel is inertia in the unramified extension $L_{\infty }/F_{\infty }$, hence trivial, and the map onto the totally ramified base inertia is surjective. Thus each image in $D_n$ is procyclic and has ${\mathbb{Z}}_p$-rank at most one. No other finite prime contributes inertia. Quotienting $D_n$ by the closed subgroup generated by these $s$ images gives an abelian extension of $F_n$ unramified at all finite primes. Its Galois group is finite by class field theory, using the ordinary or narrow ideal class group according to the treatment of real places. Any infinite-place inertia is finite and does not affect the rank bound. Therefore $D_n$ is finitely generated over ${\mathbb{Z}}_p$ andThe preceding exact sequence now yields the uniform boundIt does not assert that these coinvariant modules are always finite when several primes ramify.

At $n=0$, $Y/TY$ is finitely generated over ${\mathbb{Z}}_p$, so $Y/(p,T)Y$ is finite. Lift a finite basis of this quotient to $Y$. The Compact Nakayama lemma shows that these lifts generate $Y$ over $\Lambda$. Briefly, the quotient by their compact generated image satisfies $Q=(p,T)Q$. Every finite continuous $\Lambda$-quotient of $Q$ has nilpotent action by $(p,T)$: $p$ is nilpotent, and modulo $p$ a finite pro-$p$ action makes $\gamma -1$ nilpotent. Such a quotient must be zero. Finite quotients separate points of a compact pro-p group, so $Q=0$.

Suppose now that $Y$ had positive $\Lambda$-rank $r$. The Iwasawa module structure theorem provides a pseudo-isomorphism towith $E$ a finitely generated torsion module. Passing to ${\Gamma }_n$-coinvariant modules leaves a finite cokernel. Butis free of rank $p^n$ over ${\mathbb{Z}}_p$. Thus the coinvariant modules would have rank at least $r{p}^n$, contradicting the uniform bound $s-1$. Equivalently their ranks have asymptotic form $r{p}^n+O(1)$, with the torsion elementary divisors contributing only a bounded rank.

It follows that $r=0$. Since $\Lambda$ is an integral domain, rank zero means every element is killed by a nonzero scalar. ThereforeThis is the unramified Iwasawa torsion theorem. The crucial arithmetic inputs are finite class fields and the bounded number of ramified primes; neither vanishing of a $\mu$-invariant nor a cyclotomic main conjecture is required.

The point to retain in the direct-image theorem is quasi-compactness of inverse images of affine opens and of overlaps; no separation assumption has been supplied. The underlying space of a Noetherian scheme is Noetherian, so every open subset of $X$ is quasi-compact. Fix an affine open subscheme $V=\mathrm{Spec}A$ of $Y$, put $W=f^{-1}V$, and choose a finite open cover by affine open subschemes $W={\bigcup }_i{U}_i$. For each pair $i,j$, choose a finite affine cover $(W_{ij\ell }{)}_{\ell }$ of $U_i\cap U_j$. Empty overlaps contribute no terms.

Write $M=\Gamma (W,\mathcal{F})$. The sheaf gluing axiom gives the exact sequencewhere $\delta$ is the difference of the two restrictions to each overlap chart. All terms are $A$-modules through $f$. For $a\in A$, the inverse image of $D(a)$ cuts each $U_i$ and $W_{ij\ell }$ by a principal open subscheme. Because $\mathcal{F}$ is a quasi-coherent sheaf, sections on these smaller affine charts are the corresponding module localizations at $a$. Exactness of localization and its commutation with finite products now identify the localized equalizer with the equalizer for the restricted cover. ThusThe isomorphisms respect restrictions, proving $(f_{\ast }\mathcal{F}){|}_V\cong \tilde{M}$ on the basis of principal open subschemes. Since $V$ was arbitrary, $f_{\ast }\mathcal{F}$ is a quasi-coherent sheaf. The finite covers of overlaps are what allow the proof to work for nonseparated Noetherian schemes; this is the quasi-coherence of direct image under a quasi-compact quasi-separated morphism.

For a quasi-coherent sheaf which is not coherent but has coherent direct image, use $f:{\mathbb{P}}_k^1\to \mathrm{Spec}k$ andThis infinite negative-twist sum with zero global sections is quasi-coherent: on each standard affine chart it is the sheaf associated with a direct sum of free rank-one modules. Its stalk at every point, modulo the maximal ideal, is an infinite-dimensional vector space. A finitely generated module would have a finite-dimensional quotient, so $\mathcal{F}$ is not a coherent sheaf.

Nevertheless, $\Gamma ({\mathbb{P}}^1,\mathcal{O}(-1))=0$. This follows from cohomology of twisting sheaves on projective space, or directly by gluing on the two standard affine charts: if $z=t_1/t_0$, a section is a polynomial $p(z)$ on the first chart and $q(z^{-1})$ on the second with $p(z)=z^{-1}q(z^{-1})$, which forces both to vanish. Global sections commute with this direct sum: they are the kernel of the difference map for the two-chart cover, and direct sums commute with that finite equalizer of modules. Hencewhich is coherent on $\mathrm{Spec}k$. Both schemes in this example are Noetherian.

For a finite morphism, such an example is impossible. On an affine open subscheme $V=\mathrm{Spec}A$ of the target, its inverse image is $\mathrm{Spec}B$, with $B$ a finite $A$-module. Write $\mathcal{F}{|}_{f^{-1}V}=\tilde{M}$. Its direct image corresponds to $M$ considered as an $A$-module. If the direct image is coherent, $M$ is finitely generated over $A$. The same generators also generate it over $B$, because $A$ acts through $B$. Since $B$ is Noetherian, $\tilde{M}$ is coherent. Conversely, a finite set of $B$-generators combined with a finite set of $A$-generators of $B$ gives finitely many $A$-generators of $M$. Thus coherence reflected by finite direct image gives the stronger equivalence

Finally, let $Y=\mathrm{Spec}k[x,y]$, let $X=Y\setminus \{(x,y)\}$ be the punctured affine plane, and let $j:X\hookrightarrow Y$ be the open immersion. Both are integral schemes, but $j$ is not an isomorphism of schemes because it omits a point. The cover $X=D(x)\cup D(y)$ givesinside the field of fractions $k(x,y)$. Indeed, in a reduced fraction, membership in the first localization forces every denominator factor to be associated to $x$, while membership in the second forces it to be associated to $y$. Unique factorization and coprimality force the denominator to be a unit. By the theorem just proved, $j_{\ast }{\mathcal{O}}_X$ is quasi-coherent on the affine $Y$, hence determined by this module of global sections. The natural map ${\mathcal{O}}_Y\to j_{\ast }{\mathcal{O}}_X$ corresponds to the identity of $k[x,y]$, soa coherent sheaf. This is a concrete case of codimension-two extension of regular functions on a normal variety.