An instrumental variable changes an exposure or treatment but affects the outcome only through that exposure. Together, instrument relevance, instrumental-variable independence, and the exclusion restriction identify causal effects under suitable structural assumptions.
For a binary instrumental variable , exposure , and outcome , the Wald estimator is the ratio of the instrument's effect on the outcome to its effect on the exposure:Under instrumental-variable assumptions it estimates a causal effect.
Instrument relevance requires the instrumental variable to change the conditional distribution of the exposure. A nearly irrelevant instrument is a weak instrument and can produce unstable estimates.
A weak instrument has only a small association with the endogenous exposure, making instrumental-variable estimators imprecise and potentially badly biased in finite samples.
Instrumental-variable independence requires the instrument to be independent of unmeasured causes of the outcome, usually conditionally on specified observed covariates.
The exclusion restriction requires an instrumental variable to affect the outcome only through the exposure whose causal effect is being studied.
Mendelian randomization uses inherited genetic variants associated with an exposure as instrumental variables. Its causal interpretation requires instrument relevance, instrumental-variable independence, and the exclusion restriction.
Within-family Mendelian randomization uses genetic contrasts within families, such as differences between siblings. Conditioning on shared parental background can reduce population stratification and family-level sources of confounding, although the exclusion restriction and sufficient instrument relevance remain necessary.
MR-Egger regression fits genetic outcome associations to genetic exposure associations with a free intercept. Its slope estimates a causal effect under the InSIDE assumption and appropriate instrument-strength assumptions; its intercept assesses average directional horizontal pleiotropy. A nonsignificant intercept, especially with few genetic variants, does not prove the exclusion restriction for every instrument.
InSIDE stands for instrument strength independent of direct effect. It requires the genetic associations with the exposure to be independent of the direct, pleiotropic effects of those genetic variants on the outcome. It is a key identifying assumption for MR-Egger regression.
This weighted median of genetic variant ratio estimates consistently estimates a common causal effect when more than half of its asymptotic weight comes from valid instrumental variables, subject to the usual sampling regularity conditions. It is a sensitivity analysis for horizontal pleiotropy, not an unconditional guarantee of validity.
Two-sample Mendelian randomization combines genetic variant associations with an exposure estimated in one sample and their associations with an outcome estimated in another. It requires the instrumental variable assumptions and compatible associations across the populations; sample overlap can change the behaviour of weak instruments.
Horizontal pleiotropy occurs when a genetic instrument affects an outcome through a pathway other than the exposure under study. It violates the exclusion restriction in Mendelian randomization.
Residual exposure stratification subtracts the genetically predicted component of an exposure before forming exposure strata. Under a suitable additive first-stage model, this avoids directly conditioning on the component caused by the instrument and can reduce the resulting collider bias.
A confounder-instrument interaction occurs when an instrument's effect on treatment varies with a variable that also affects the outcome. If the conditional first-stage effect is , absence of this interaction means that is constant.
Instrumental-variable monotonicity requires changing the instrument in its encouraging direction never to move any unit's exposure in the opposite direction.
The local average treatment effect is the average causal effect among compliers, the units whose treatment status changes in the direction encouraged by the instrument.
Articles by others on the same topic
There are currently no matching articles.