The joint dependence of leave-one-out consensus residuals arises because different laboratories' benchmarks reuse many of the same observations. Excluding each result from its own leave-one-out interlaboratory consensus does not make the complete collection of residuals independent.
Let be fixed positive coefficients with , and let be the full weighted mean. With at least two observations, every , and the omitted-result residual isWrite for the weighted centering matrix, and for a diagonal matrix. ThenEach row of sums to zero, so each residual is a contrast: a common additive level cancels.
For independent observations with positive variances , define . Expanding linearity of covariance givesEqual coefficients and equal variances reduce these expressions toThe familiar negative covariance belongs to this model. Arbitrary fixed coefficients can produce a different sign.
An original three-laboratory counterexample sets and . Then , andThis positive covariance has a simple cause: both benchmarks are dominated by the third result. Increasing pushes both and downward. The coefficients are stipulated to expose the dependence; with equal observation variances, they are not inverse-variance coefficients.
For positive inverse-variance weights , where , one has and . The off-diagonal expression becomesThus the leave-one-out inverse-variance weighted consensus has a special sign pattern under its independent known-variance assumptions.
The coefficients also impose a deterministic constraint,Consequently the residual covariance matrix is a singular matrix. Under the independent-observation model with every , its matrix rank is : the weighted centering matrix removes the common-level direction and the invertible diagonal matrix preserves that rank. For equal coefficients the constraint is simply .
These dependencies matter when evaluating several laboratories together. Products of single-residual probabilities generally do not describe joint events. A specified joint model or a set of appropriately chosen contrasts can represent the available information without treating redundant residuals as independent observations.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 iii Paper 35 2 d Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
A fixed-effect meta-analysis assigns inverse-variance weights. Using the unrounded within-study variance from part (b), this trial has , so its percentage weight isUsing the printed rounded standard error of instead gives approximately ; the raw cell calculation yields the more precise answer.
For a random-effects meta-analysis, the corresponding weight and percentage weight areWith , its unnormalised weight is . The supplied sums of fixed-effect weights do not determine the denominator of the random-effects percentage; the individual are needed. Positive heterogeneity makes the weight distribution more even. Percentage weight measures the trial's contribution to a pooled mean with fixed weights; total influence can also involve re-estimation of heterogeneity.
