The joint dependence of leave-one-out consensus residuals arises because different laboratories' benchmarks reuse many of the same observations. Excluding each result from its own leave-one-out interlaboratory consensus does not make the complete collection of residuals independent.
Let be fixed positive coefficients with , and let be the full weighted mean. With at least two observations, every , and the omitted-result residual is
Write for the weighted centering matrix, and for a diagonal matrix. Then
Each row of sums to zero, so each residual is a contrast: a common additive level cancels.
For independent observations with positive variances , define . Expanding linearity of covariance gives
Equal coefficients and equal variances reduce these expressions to
The familiar negative covariance belongs to this model. Arbitrary fixed coefficients can produce a different sign.
An original three-laboratory counterexample sets and . Then , and
This positive covariance has a simple cause: both benchmarks are dominated by the third result. Increasing pushes both and downward. The coefficients are stipulated to expose the dependence; with equal observation variances, they are not inverse-variance coefficients.
Figure 1.
Leave-one-out residual correlation depends on both coefficients and observation variances
. Original three-laboratory models with independent unit-variance observations. Equal coefficients give negative pairwise correlation; a dominant third coefficient creates positive correlation between the first two residuals. Details.
For positive inverse-variance weights , where , one has and . The off-diagonal expression becomes
Thus the leave-one-out inverse-variance weighted consensus has a special sign pattern under its independent known-variance assumptions.
The coefficients also impose a deterministic constraint,
Consequently the residual covariance matrix is a singular matrix. Under the independent-observation model with every , its matrix rank is : the weighted centering matrix removes the common-level direction and the invertible diagonal matrix preserves that rank. For equal coefficients the constraint is simply .
These dependencies matter when evaluating several laboratories together. Products of single-residual probabilities generally do not describe joint events. A specified joint model or a set of appropriately chosen contrasts can represent the available information without treating redundant residuals as independent observations.
A fixed-effect meta-analysis assigns inverse-variance weights. Using the unrounded within-study variance from part (b), this trial has , so its percentage weight is
Using the printed rounded standard error of instead gives approximately ; the raw cell calculation yields the more precise answer.
For a random-effects meta-analysis, the corresponding weight and percentage weight are
With , its unnormalised weight is . The supplied sums of fixed-effect weights do not determine the denominator of the random-effects percentage; the individual are needed. Positive heterogeneity makes the weight distribution more even. Percentage weight measures the trial's contribution to a pooled mean with fixed weights; total influence can also involve re-estimation of heterogeneity.