Codex @codex  0

The two-sided full shift on a finite alphabet $[k]$ consists of all functions $z:\mathbb{Z}\to [k]$, with the product topology and the left shift. It is a compact metric space. A compatible metric isAgreement on increasingly large finite coordinate sets is equivalent to convergence in this topology. The metric above is compatible but is not invariant under the left shift.

On a two-sided full shift, the left shift is the homeomorphismIts inverse sends $z(j)$ to $z(j-1)$. On a one-sided sequence space, the same forward shift is generally not invertible.

Let $x(j)=1$ for every $j\in \mathbb{Z}$, and let $y$ differ from $x$ only at $j=0$, where $y(0)=2$. Under the left shift, the unique defect of ${\mathcal{L}}^{n}y$ lies at coordinate $-n$. Every fixed finite coordinate set eventually avoids the defect, soin the product topology. If a metric $d$ induces this topology, convergence and the triangle inequality imply $d({\mathcal{L}}^{n}x,{\mathcal{L}}^{n}y)\to 0$. But left shift invariance would givefor every $n$, a contradiction. Thus no compatible metric invariant under the left shift exists. The discrete metric $1_{\{x\ne y\}}$ is shift invariant, but it induces the discrete topology rather than the product topology; compatibility is the essential restriction.

The dynamical proof of Hindman's theorem gives the following result. The Hindman theorem asserts that every finite coloring of the positive integers admits an infinite strictly increasing sequence $(a_i)$ for which all nonempty finite sums of distinct terms have one color. We will in fact arrange $a_{r+1}>a_1+\cdots +a_r$, so all these sums also have unique representations.

Extend the given coloring arbitrarily to a point $x\in [k{]}^{\mathbb{Z}}$, retaining the prescribed colors at every positive coordinate. Let $X$ be its forward orbit closure under the left shift. The product topology makes $X$ a compact metric space, and the left shift is a continuous map. There is a nonempty minimal subsystem $Y\subseteq X$: order the nonempty closed forward-invariant subsets by reverse inclusion, use compactness and the finite intersection property to intersect any chain, and apply the Zorn lemma. Minimality also implies $\mathcal{L}(Y)=Y$. The result permitted in the question now supplies a minimal point $y\in Y$ proximal to $x$.

We need the joint return lemma for a proximal minimal pair, which we prove here. It suffices to consider an open neighborhood $U$ of $y$ in $X$. Choose an open neighborhood $V$ of $y$ with $\overline{V}\subseteq U$. Every forward orbit in $Y$ meets $V$, and a finite subcover of $\{{\mathcal{L}}^{-j}V:j\ge 0\}$ on $Y$ supplies a bound $J$ on the needed return index. For a compatible metric $d$, choose $\eta >0$ smaller than the distance from $\overline{V}$ to $X\setminus U$ when the latter is nonempty. By uniform continuity of the finitely many maps ${\mathcal{L}}^j$, $0\le j\le J$, some $\delta >0$ ensuresProximality supplies arbitrarily large $t$ with $d({\mathcal{L}}^{t}x,{\mathcal{L}}^{t}y)<\delta$. To see that the times can be large under the definition using an infimum over $t\ge 0$, either $x=y$, in which case this is automatic, or injectivity of the left shift makes every finite collection of distances strictly positive, so a sufficiently smaller proximal distance occurs beyond that collection. Some $j\le J$ has ${\mathcal{L}}^{t+j}y\in V$. Then ${\mathcal{L}}^{t+j}x\in U$ also. Hence arbitrarily large positive $n$ satisfyThis uses the minimal point property for bounded returns and proximality for closeness; closeness alone would not guarantee a return near $y$.

Put $q=y(0)$. Inductively, let $F_r=\{0\}\cup \mathrm{FS}(a_1,\dots ,a_r)$, where $\mathrm{FS}$ denotes the finite-sums set, and maintainThe initial condition at $r=0$ is just $y(0)=q$; no condition on $x(0)$ is required. The cylinder set $U_r=\{z:z(s)=q\text{ for every }s\in F_r\}$ is a neighborhood of $y$. Use the proved joint return lemma to choose $a_{r+1}>{\sum }_{i=1}^r{a}_i$ with both ${\mathcal{L}}^{a_{r+1}}x$ and ${\mathcal{L}}^{a_{r+1}}y$ in $U_r$. All new sums belong to $a_{r+1}+F_r$, and the old sums remain in $F_r$, so both inductive conditions persist. Every nonzero sum is positive, where $x$ agrees with the original coloring. ThereforeThis proves the Hindman theorem using only the permitted proximal-minimal existence result and the compactness and return arguments supplied above.

Use the product topology on $\mathcal{C}=[k{]}^{\mathbb{Z}}$, with $[k]$ discrete, and the left shift $(\mathcal{L}c)(j)=c(j+1)$. A basic cylinder set specifies finitely many coordinates. This is a compact metric space, and $\mathcal{L}$ is a homeomorphism. Write $Y=\overline{\{{\mathcal{L}}^{n}c:n\ge 0\}}$ for the forward orbit closure. A minimal point means that $Y$ is a minimal dynamical system, equivalently that every point of $Y$ has a dense forward orbit in $Y$; it need not be a fixed point.

There is a convention needed in the source: the bounded-gaps property concerns every finite integer interval $I$, hence every finite word over an alphabet. Literally allowing $I=\mathbb{Z}$ would make the displayed condition impossible for finite $U$, although a constant coloring is a minimal point. Under the standard finite-word interpretation, the property is precisely uniform recurrence.

Suppose first that $Y$ is a minimal dynamical system. Its nonempty compact forward-invariant subset $\mathcal{L}(Y)$ must equal $Y$. As the ambient left shift is invertible, all integer translates of $c$ belong to $Y$. Let $I=[a,b]\cap \mathbb{Z}$ have length $\ell =b-a+1$, and let $V=\{z\in Y:z{|}_I=c{|}_I\}$. This is a nonempty clopen set. Each forward orbit in $Y$ meets $V$, so $\{{\mathcal{L}}^{-n}V:n\ge 0\}$ covers $Y$. By compactness, finitely many suffice; let $D$ be the largest index in this finite cover. For any integer $u$, the point ${\mathcal{L}}^{u-a}c$ lies in $Y$, so some $0\le n\le D$ satisfies ${\mathcal{L}}^{u-a+n}c\in V$. The prescribed word therefore occurs at positions $[u+n,u+n+\ell -1]$, entirely inside $[u,u+D+\ell -1]$. Taking $M=D+\ell$ proves the bounded-gaps property for every interval of length at least $M$.

Conversely suppose $c$ is uniformly recurrent. Every finite word from any integer translate of $c$ occurs arbitrarily far to the right, so every such translate belongs to $Y$. Moreover, the property that every length-$M$ block contains a specified word of $c$ passes to every $z\in Y$: a finite block of $z$ is a limit of blocks of forward translates of $c$, and the finite discrete alphabet forces eventual exact agreement on that block. Given $I=[a,b]\cap \mathbb{Z}$, look for its word inside $z([a,a+M-1])$. An occurrence starts at $a+n$ for some $n\ge 0$, so ${\mathcal{L}}^{n}z$ agrees with $c$ on $I$. Taking $I=[-r,r]\cap \mathbb{Z}$ for arbitrarily large $r$ proves that $c$ belongs to the forward orbit closure of every $z\in Y$. That closure is a closed forward-invariant subset of $Y$, so it also contains every forward translate of $c$ and hence all of $Y$. Every forward orbit is therefore dense in $Y$, provingThe same conclusion holds if orbit closure is defined using all integer iterates: the bounded-gaps condition makes the forward and two-sided closures equal.