Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 22 1 iii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Let be the projective cubic of a Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve, allowing its elliptic-curve discriminant to vanish, and let . Use only the smooth locus of a variety : the singular point, if present, is excluded. For , intersect their chord with , using the tangent if and counting intersection multiplicity. If the third intersection is , define , wherein general Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve coordinates. The line through and gives this reflection. A vertical chord gives , and the tangent at meets three times at , so is the identity. The construction is symmetric in . It stays in the nonsingular locus: a line through a singular point has intersection multiplicity at least two there, and therefore cannot also contain two smooth intersections counted with multiplicity.
For the nonsingular case, prove associativity by transporting a known abelian group law. The Abel-Jacobi map of a genus-one curveis bijective over an algebraic closure. Indeed, the Riemann-Roch theorem in genus one says that every divisor class of degree one has a unique effective representative consisting of one point: existence follows from , and uniqueness follows because two distinct representatives would produce a degree-one map to the projective line, impossible for a genus one curve. Subtracting gives the claimed bijection.
Any line section represents the same divisor class as , including tangencies. Thus as divisors on an algebraic curve, while the vertical line gives . HenceAddition in the Picard group is associative, soThe chord-and-tangent group law is defined over , so the group operation restricts to the -rational points.
For completeness, a singular Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve produces the smooth-locus group of a singular Weierstrass cubic, not an elliptic curve. Over an algebraic closure, its normalization of an algebraic curve is the projective line; deleting the two preimages of a nodal crossing gives the multiplicative algebraic group, while deleting the single preimage of a cusp gives the additive group. For example, on , the coordinate , with , makes the smooth-locus law addition. On in characteristic different from two, put and , with ; the chord relation gives , so the group law is multiplication of . A nonsplit node gives the corresponding form of the multiplicative algebraic group over . These descriptions also establish the singular-case group laws.
Topological manifold local obstruction Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-11-05
A local obstruction must apply to neighborhoods that would have to model a Euclidean ball, rather than to an arbitrarily chosen disconnected or large neighborhood. For a nodal crossing, two complex discs meet only at their common center. Removing that center from any sufficiently small connected neighborhood leaves at least two connected components, one in each branch.
In contrast, a connected open subset of remains connected after one point is removed: paths can be detoured around that point inside a small disc. Thus the nodal crossing has no neighborhood homeomorphic to a planar ball and is not a two-dimensional topological manifold there. Path avoidance in a surface gives the same local argument. Finding a disconnected punctured neighborhood without controlling its local form would not establish this obstruction.