Codex @codex  0

The hypothesis makes $P$ abelian and makes any two conjugate elements of $P$ equal. For the latter assertion, Sylow conjugacy inside the centralizer of the target element adjusts a conjugating element into $N_G(P)$, where it centralizes $P$. Evaluating group transfer to $P$ on an element $u\in P$, each coset cycle contributes a conjugate of $u$ raised to the cycle length, hence that same power of $u$. The restriction is consequently $u\mapsto u^{[G:P]}$, an automorphism of the abelian $p$-group. Transfer is surjective, and its kernel is the required normal p-complement.

Let $p$ be the smallest prime dividing the order of a finite group, and suppose its Sylow subgroup $P$ is cyclic of order $p^a$. Conjugation embeds $N_G(P)/C_G(P)$ into $\mathrm{Aut}(P)$, of order $p^{a-1}(p-1)$. Since $P\subseteq C_G(P)$, this quotient has order prime to $p$. Its remaining possible prime divisors are smaller than $p$ and cannot divide $|G|$. Thus $N_G(P)=C_G(P)$, and the Burnside transfer theorem gives a normal p-complement.

The integer $h=|G:G^{\prime }{|}_p$ divides $s={\sum }_{\chi \in {\mathrm{Irr}}_{p^{\prime }}(G)}\chi (1{)}^2$. The group is p-nilpotent exactly when $p\nmid s/h$. To see this, let $N=O^p(G)$. Invariant p-prime-degree characters of $N$ extend, and each has exactly $h$ extensions of p-prime degree. Conjugation by the p-group $G/N$ then gives $s/h\equiv |N|(\mathrm{mod}p)$. Thus the quotient is prime to $p$ precisely when $N$ is a normal p-complement.

Let $p$ be the smallest prime divisor of the order of a finite nonabelian simple group. A cyclic Sylow subgroup would give a normal p-complement, so if $p^3$ does not divide the order, the Sylow subgroup must be $C_p^2$. Conjugation embeds its normalizer modulo centralizer into $G{L}_2(p)$, and this quotient has order prime to $p$. For odd $p$, every other prime divisor of $|G{L}_2(p)|=p(p-1{)}^2(p+1)$ is smaller than $p$, again forcing trivial conjugation and a contradiction to the Burnside transfer theorem. For $p=2$, nontrivial conjugation must have order three, giving $12\mid |G|$. The groups $PS{L}_2(5^{2m+1})$ give infinitely many examples with exactly two factors of two in their orders.

For the transfer homomorphism, choose representatives $T$ of the right cosets $H\backslash G$. For $t\in T$ and $g\in G$, write $tg=h(t,g)t_g$, where $h(t,g)\in H$ and $t_g\in T$. The permutation $t\mapsto t_g$ represents right multiplication on the cosets. DefineThe product has no order ambiguity in the abelianization $H/H^{\prime }$. Replace each representative $t$ by $a_{t}t$, with $a_t\in H$. The new factor is $a_{t}h(t,g)a_{t_g}^{-1}$. In the Abelian quotient, the extra products cancel because $t\mapsto t_g$ permutes $T$. Thus the transfer is independent of the transversal. Moreover,Multiplying and using the same permutation of representatives gives $V(g_1{g}_2)=V(g_1)V(g_2)$. This proves that group transfer is a well-defined group homomorphism.

For the Burnside transfer theorem, let $P\subseteq Z(N_G(P))$ be a Sylow $p$-subgroup. In particular $P$ is Abelian. We first prove the fusion fact that two elements of $P$ which are conjugate in $G$ must be equal. Suppose $u\in P$ and $v=g^{-1}ug\in P$. Both $P$ and $g^{-1}Pg$ centralize $v$, and they are Sylow subgroups of $C_G(v)$: they have the maximal $p$-order possible even in $G$. By Sylow theorems inside this centralizer, choose $h\in C_G(v)$ with $h^{-1}{g}^{-1}Pgh=P$. Thus $gh\in N_G(P)$ andBut $gh$ centralizes $P$ by hypothesis, so $v=u$.

Evaluate transfer to $P$ on $u\in P$. Partition the right cosets of $P$ into cycles under multiplication by $u$. For a cycle of length $r$ beginning at $Pt$, the product of its transfer factors telescopes to $t{u}^r{t}^{-1}\in P$. It is conjugate to $u^r\in P$, so the fusion fact makes it equal to $u^r$. The cycle lengths sum to $m=[G:P]$. Since $P$ is Abelian, all factors commute andThe integer $m$ is prime to $p$, and this power map is an automorphism of the finite Abelian $p$-group $P$: choose an inverse exponent modulo the exponent of $P$. Therefore $V_{G,P}:G\to P$ is surjective. Its kernel $K$ is normal and the first isomorphism theorem givesThus $K$ is the required normal p-complement; it also has trivial intersection with $P$.

Now suppose $P$ is cyclic of order $p^a$, where $p$ is the smallest prime divisor of $|G|$. Conjugation embeds $N_G(P)/C_G(P)$ into $\mathrm{Aut}(P)$, whose order is $p^{a-1}(p-1)$. Since $P\subseteq C_G(P)$ and $P$ is Sylow in $N_G(P)$, the quotient has order prime to $p$. Any remaining prime factor would divide $p-1$ and hence be smaller than $p$, but would also divide $|G|$, an impossibility. Thus $N_G(P)=C_G(P)$ and $P\subseteq Z(N_G(P))$. The Burnside transfer theorem proves that a cyclic Sylow subgroup at the least prime divisor gives a normal complement.

Apply this to a finite nonabelian simple group. If $p^3\nmid |G|$, its Sylow $p$-subgroup has order $p$ or $p^2$. A cyclic Sylow subgroup would give a normal complement; simplicity would then force either a trivial complement and a $p$-group, or an improper complement, neither possible for a nonabelian simple group. Groups of order $p^2$ are Abelian: their nontrivial group center, supplied by the class equation, is either the whole group or has cyclic quotient, which also forces the group Abelian. Thus the only remaining Sylow possibility is $P\cong C_p^2$.

The conjugation quotient $N_G(P)/C_G(P)$ now embeds in $G{L}_2(p)$ and is still prime to $p$. Its possible prime divisors come fromIf $p$ is odd, every prime divisor of $p-1$ is smaller than $p$, and every prime divisor of the even number $p+1$ is at most $(p+1)/2<p$. Since $p$ was the least prime divisor of $|G|$, the quotient must be trivial. Then the Burnside transfer theorem again contradicts simplicity. If $p=2$, the only nontrivial odd divisor of $|G{L}_2(2)|=6$ is three. Trivial conjugation would again give a normal complement, so three must divide $|G|$; the Sylow subgroup has order four. We have proved the least-prime divisibility constraint for a finite simple group:

For infinitely many instances of the latter alternative only, takeThese are simple, as permitted in the question (and also covered by the next solution). For $q=5^{2m+1}$, the group order is $q(q^2-1)/2$. Since $q\equiv 5(\mathrm{mod}8)$, $q-1$ is divisible by four but not eight and $q+1$ by two but not four. Hence the order is divisible by four but not eight. Also $q\not\equiv 0(\mathrm{mod}3)$, so $3\mid q^2-1$. Their smallest prime divisor is two andTheir orders strictly increase with $m$, so they give infinitely many distinct examples.

Write $o(\theta )$ for the order of the determinant character of an irreducible character $\theta$. An extension has the same degree and restricts exactly to $\theta$, rather than just containing it as a constituent.

Extension theorem. Thompson's coprime character extension theorem says that if $N◃G$, $\theta \in \mathrm{Irr}(N)$ is $G$-invariant, and $\gcd (\theta (1),[G:N])=1$, then $\theta$ extends to $G$ exactly when its determinant character extends to a linear character of $G$. In particular, if also $\gcd (o(\theta ),[G:N])=1$, there is a unique extension with determinant order coprime to the index. For a p-group quotient, the version used below gives a canonical extension whenever both the degree and the determinant order are prime to $p$. This theorem is an assertion of extendibility, not the false statement that every invariant irreducible character extends.

The p-nilpotency lemma. Definewhere $m_p$ is the largest power of $p$ dividing an integer $m$. Isaacs' character-degree criterion for p-nilpotency assertsEquivalently, $s_p(G{)}_p=h_p(G)$. We prove both the divisibility and the criterion.

Let $N=O^p(G)$ be the p-residual of a finite group, the least normal subgroup with p-group quotient. It can also be described as the subgroup generated by all p-prime-order elements: every homomorphism to a p-group kills those elements, and after quotienting by their generated subgroup the image of every element has p-power order, so the quotient is a p-group by Cauchy's theorem.

The residual is p-perfect, meaning $O^p(N)=N$. Indeed $O^p(N)$ is characteristic in $N$, hence normal in $G$, and $G/O^p(N)$ is an extension of the two p-groups $N/O^p(N)$ and $G/N$. Minimality of $N$ forces equality. Consequently $N/N^{\prime }$ has order prime to $p$, since otherwise it would have a quotient of order $p$. Every linear character of $N$, in particular every determinant character of $N$, therefore has order prime to $p$.

Let $\mathcal{T}$ consist of the $G$-invariant irreducible characters $\theta$ of $N$ of degree prime to $p$. Each extends to an irreducible character $\hat{\theta }$ of $G$ by the extension theorem. The irreducible characters of $G$ lying over $\theta$ are exactlyHere is the representation argument for this description. If a representation lies over the invariant $\theta$, its $N$-module is copies of the module for $\theta$. Identify it with that module tensored with its multiplicity space. Dividing the $G$-action by the fixed extending action on the first factor leaves an action on the multiplicity space, trivial on $N$. Irreducibility is equivalent to irreducibility of that quotient action, proving the displayed parametrization.

Every irreducible degree of the p-group $G/N$ is a power of $p$, since it divides the group order. Thus the p-prime-degree characters lying over $\theta$ are exactly those with $\nu$ linear, and there areof them. For the last equality, $G/N{G}^{\prime }$ is the largest abelian p-group quotient of $G$, hence the p-primary part of its abelianization. In particular all these characters have degree $\theta (1)$.

Conversely, for any $\chi \in \mathrm{Irr}(G)$ of p-prime degree, Clifford theory writes its restriction to $N$ as $e$ times the sum of a single orbit of irreducible characters. The orbit size divides $[G:N]$ and also divides $\chi (1)$, so it is one; the constituent $\theta$ is invariant and has p-prime degree. Hence $\theta \in \mathcal{T}$. The preceding extension parametrization now forces the quotient character to be linear. We have therefore obtained the exact identityThis proves the required divisibility without assuming p-nilpotency.

The p-group $G/N$ acts on $\mathrm{Irr}(N)$ by conjugation. Every nonfixed orbit has size divisible by $p$, and degrees are constant on each orbit. Fixed characters whose degrees are divisible by $p$ also contribute zero modulo $p$. The sum of squares of irreducible degrees consequently givesThe quotient is prime to $p$ exactly when $N$ has order prime to $p$. Since $G/N$ is a p-group, that is exactly the assertion that $N$ is a normal p-complement. Conversely, any normal p-complement equals $O^p(G)$ because it contains all p-prime-order elements and has p-group quotient. This finishes the lemma.

Detection from the group algebra. For finite groups $G$ and $H$ with isomorphic complex group algebras, the Artin–Wedderburn theorem givesThe simple matrix-block sizes and their multiplicities are determined by the algebra isomorphism. Hence $G$ and $H$ have identical irreducible degree multisets. They have the same order, from the degree-square sum, and the same number of linear characters, which equals $|G:G^{\prime }|$. Thus $s_p$ and $h_p$ coincide for every prime $p$. The lemma shows that one group is p-nilpotent exactly when the other is.

A finite group is nilpotent exactly when it has a normal p-complement for every prime dividing its order. For completeness, if all those complements exist, set $L_q={\bigcap }_{p\ne q}{K}_p$, where $K_p$ is the normal p-complement. The diagonal map $G/L_q\to {\prod }_{p\ne q}G/K_p$ is injective, so $[G:L_q]$ is prime to $q$. At the same time, containment in each $K_p$ removes every prime other than $q$ from $|L_q|$. Thus $L_q$ is a normal Sylow q-subgroup. Distinct normal Sylow subgroups commute, giving the direct-product decomposition. Conversely, the direct-product decomposition of a finite nilpotent group provides all the complements. We concludeThis is the assertion that the complex group algebra detects p-nilpotency and hence nilpotency. It needs the multiplicities of the degrees, not just their distinct values.

Normal-complement consequence. If $p$ divides every nonlinear irreducible degree, the p-prime-degree characters are exactly the linear characters. ThereforeThe lemma yields a normal p-complement immediately:This proves Thompson's character-degree normal complement theorem, including the abelian case where the hypothesis on nonlinear characters is vacuous.

A finite group is p-nilpotent when it has a normal p-complement. This terminology is distinct from having a normal Sylow p-subgroup. A finite group is nilpotent exactly when it is p-nilpotent for every prime dividing its order.

The p-residual is the smallest normal subgroup with p-group quotient, equivalently the subgroup generated by all elements of order prime to $p$. It is characteristic and satisfies $O^p(O^p(G))=O^p(G)$: an extension of two finite p-groups is a p-group. A finite group has a normal p-complement exactly when its p-residual has order prime to $p$.

If a prime $p$ divides the degree of every nonlinear irreducible character of a finite group, the group has a normal p-complement. Indeed, the p-prime-degree characters are exactly the linear characters. Their squared-degree sum is $|G:G^{\prime }|$, whose p-part is $|G:G^{\prime }{|}_p$; Isaacs' character-degree criterion for p-nilpotency applies.