Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 108 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Use the probability-system convention . The Birkhoff ergodic theorem, also called the pointwise ergodic theorem, states that for a measure-preserving system and ,where is the invariant sigma-algebra. The limit is integrable and has the same integral as . On a probability space the convergence also holds in , as in the allowed mean ergodic theorem. If is an ergodic transformation, is trivial modulo null sets, giving
The integer multiplication map on the circle preserves Lebesgue measure: for any integrable on ,To prove the ergodicity of integer multiplication on the circle, suppose satisfies . Let be its Fourier coefficients in the Fourier basis . Since , the Fourier coefficients of at index are zero if does not divide , and are otherwise. This identity holds for all functions by approximation with trigonometric polynomials and the isometry . Invariance givesEvery nonzero integer can be divided by only finitely often. Thus for every , and completeness of the Fourier basis makes constant almost everywhere. Applying this to the indicator function of an invariant set gives measure zero or one, so
A normal number in base has every word of base- digits occurring with limiting overlapping frequency . Use the expansion that is not eventually equal to when there are two expansions. The word corresponds to the half-open intervalA word starting at position occurs exactly when . The Birkhoff ergodic theorem, applied to , gives frequency almost everywhere. There are countably many pairs , so their full-measure sets have a full-measure intersection. In particular,These are absolutely normal numbers, so existence follows as well. This interval description also proves normality and equidistribution under integer multiplication: the base- intervals form arbitrarily fine grids, so their frequencies imply the correct frequency for every interval by approximation from inside and outside.
For the growth assertion, put . For every , the Tonelli theorem gives the useful summability boundSince is a measure-preserving transformation, . The first Borel-Cantelli lemma shows that occurs only finitely often almost everywhere. Intersecting the resulting full-measure sets for proves the linear growth bound for integrable observables, . Multiplication by then gives
The threshold is sharp. For , choose with , and take the Bernoulli shift on with the product measure of independent uniform coordinates. The left shift preserves that measure because it preserves the probability of every finite-coordinate event. Define ; it is integrable becauseThe variables are independent. For any fixed ,The probability sum diverges, so the second Borel-Cantelli lemma makes these events occur infinitely often almost surely. Intersecting over positive integer even yields . For , the constant observable already fails to give limit zero. Thus the sharpness of the linear growth bound for integrable observables gives
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 108 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
The Rudolph measure rigidity theorem has an essential ergodicity hypothesis. If a Borel probability measure on the circle group is invariant under both and , is ergodic for the semigroup generated jointly by these maps, and either map has positive Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy, thenEquivalently, a jointly ergodic common invariant measure other than Lebesgue measure has zero entropy for both maps. Joint ergodicity means that every set invariant modulo under both maps has measure zero or one. Positive entropy without this hypothesis is insufficient: , with a Dirac measure, is a common invariant measure of positive entropy and is not .
The Host equidistribution theorem states that if are relatively prime integers and is invariant and ergodic under , with , then for -almost every the sequence is an equidistributed sequence for Lebesgue measure. Explicitly, for every continuous on the circle,The non-ergodic form assumes invariance and positive entropy for almost every component in the ergodic decomposition . Applying the ergodic theorem of Host on each such component gives the same almost-everywhere conclusion for . More generally, its conclusion holds on the part supported on positive-entropy components. A positive value of alone does not eliminate zero-entropy components.
To deduce the joint version of the Rudolph measure rigidity theorem, suppose ; if only has positive entropy, interchange the roles. Write the ergodic decomposition as . Since commutes with , its pushforward measure sends a ergodic component to a ergodic component . On each component, is a factor of a measure-preserving system with fibres of size at most three. We use the standard entropy preservation under a finite-to-one factor:The reason for this standard entropy fact is that, conditional on a complete factor point, every finite orbit name has at most three possibilities; its conditional entropy is bounded by , and division by the orbit length gives zero relative entropy.
The component at is almost everywhere; this follows from commutation and the componentwise ergodic averages. The component entropy function is therefore invariant under both and . Joint ergodicity makes it constant almost everywhere, and affinity of entropy under ergodic decomposition identifies the constant as . Thus almost every component has positive entropy, exactly the condition required in the non-ergodic Host equidistribution theorem. It follows that -almost every point equidistributes for under .
For any continuous , invariance under and the dominated convergence theorem now giveContinuous functions determine Borel probability measures on the circle, so , proving the deduction.
For the normal-number example, let be independent fair binary digits and defineThis Cantor Bernoulli measure is supported on the middle-third Cantor set . If is the Bernoulli shift, then on the circle. Consequently is invariant and ergodic: a invariant event pulls back to an invariant event, which has probability zero or one.
Take the ternary digit measurable partition . Its block partition of length has, up to null endpoints, positive-measure atoms under , each of measure , and all other atoms have measure zero. HenceApply the Host equidistribution theorem with , . For -almost every , the sequence equidistributes for Lebesgue measure, so is a normal number in base by normality and equidistribution under integer multiplication.
The ternary expansion of -almost every such contains only and , so the frequency of digit is zero rather than . The ambiguous ternary endpoints form a countable null set and can be removed. Therefore is not a normal number in base . We have proved the stronger almost-everywhere existence statement