Past exam of the logic and set theory course of the University of Oxford / 2008 / B / 6 / 1 / Solution

Use the Kuratowski ordered pairThe axiom of pairing first produces $\{a\}$ by pairing $a$ with itself, then $\{a,b\}$, and then the pair of these two sets. The axiom of extensionality supplies the usual uniqueness of each specified set. In particular, no use of Axiom schema of replacement is needed to construct a single ordered pair from two given sets.

To recover the coordinates from $P=⟨a,b⟩$, observe thatThe first equality recovers $a$. Once $a$ is known, the second recovers $b$: if its union is the singleton $\{a\}$ then $b=a$, and otherwise $b$ is its unique element different from $a$. Hence equality of two encoded pairs forces equality of both coordinates, including the degenerate case $a=b$.

The first ordered triple encoding works. Ifinjectivity of the ordered pair construction first gives $a=a^{\prime }$ and $⟨b,c⟩=⟨b^{\prime },c^{\prime }⟩$, and a second application gives $b=b^{\prime }$ and $c=c^{\prime }$. The construction uses only two successive ordered pair constructions, so is a set as well.