Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2006 / iii / Paper 25 / 11 / i

We prove the Ehrenfeucht-Mostowski theorem by ultraproducts, with no application of Ramsey theorem. Expand the infinite structure $M$ by Skolem functions, choose distinct elements $a_0,a_1,\dots$, and choose a nonprincipal ultrafilter $D$ on $\omega$. Let $I$ be the desired total index order and put $J={\omega }^I$.

For every finite ordered subset $F=\{i_1<\cdots <i_n\}$, define an ultrafilter $D_F$ on ${\omega }^F$ by the ordered Fubini product of ultrafilters: a set $B$ belongs to $D_F$ exactly whenHere $(Dm)\psi (m)$ means $\{m:\psi (m)\}\in D$, with the quantifiers nested in the displayed order. The resulting collection is an ultrafilter, by induction using the ultrafilter laws for negation and conjunction. For $F\subseteq H$, the inverse image of $B\subseteq {\omega }^F$ under coordinate projection belongs to $D_H$ exactly when $B\in D_F$: quantifiers on unused coordinates leave a truth value unchanged.

Consequently there is a well-defined ultrafilter on the Boolean algebra of finite-coordinate cylinders in $J$, declaring a cylinder large by this test. Coherence proves finite intersection closure and ensures that the empty cylinder is not large. Extend its generated filter to an ultrafilter $U$ on all subsets of $J$. Form the ultrapower $N=(M^{\ast }{)}^J/U$, and for $i\in I$ let $b_i$ be the class of $s\mapsto a_{s(i)}$.

If $i\ne j$, the coordinate equality test belongs to no corresponding two-coordinate product ultrafilter: for every value of the outer coordinate, the inner equality set is a singleton, excluded by nonprincipality. Hence the $b_i$ are distinct. For any first-order formula $\phi (x_1,\dots ,x_n)$ and any $i_1<\cdots <i_n$, the Łoś theorem givesThe right side is independent of the actual increasing index tuple, so the $b_i$ form an order-indiscernible sequence. Constant functions embed $M^{\ast }$ elementarily into $N$. Take the Skolem hull of the generators. The Tarski-Vaught test gives an elementary substructure, and transporting terms along an index-order automorphism gives a well-defined automorphism of the hull, with inverse obtained by transporting along the inverse index automorphism. Equality of term representations is preserved by indiscernibility. This is the indiscernible and automorphism conclusion of Ehrenfeucht–Mostowski, obtained entirely from ultrafilters and Łoś's theorem. The ordered Fubini products need not be symmetric; order indiscernibility is exactly what their coherence supplies.