Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2006 / iii / Paper 25 / 9 / Solution

An uncountable cardinal $\kappa$ is a measurable cardinal if there is a nonprincipal $\kappa$-complete ultrafilter $U$ on $\kappa$: intersections of fewer than $\kappa$ members of $U$ remain in $U$. Such an ultrafilter is uniform. No singleton belongs to it, and intersecting the complements of fewer than $\kappa$ singletons shows that no set of cardinality below $\kappa$ belongs to it.

Form the ultrapower of the universe by $U$, with classes $[f]$ of functions $f:\kappa \to V$, and $[f]{\in }_U[g]$ exactly when $\{\xi :f(\xi )\in g(\xi )\}\in U$. The Łoś theorem proves that the map taking $x$ to the constant function with value $x$ is elementary. The ultrapower relation is well-founded: from an infinite descending sequence $[f_0]{\ni }_U[f_1]{\ni }_U\cdots$, countable completeness gives a coordinate satisfying all the membership relations, producing an actual infinite descending membership sequence and contradicting foundation. It is also set-like. Predecessors of $[g]$ can be represented by functions whose value at $\xi$ lies in $g(\xi )\cup \{\varnothing \}$; these functions form a set. The Mostowski collapse theorem therefore gives a transitive class $N$ and an elementary embeddingThe usual class-ultrapower notation is understood via set-sized representatives and this set-like collapse.

For $\alpha <\kappa$, any function into $\alpha$ is constant on a $U$-large set: if none of its fewer-than-$\kappa$ fibers belonged to $U$, intersect their complements to get the empty set in $U$. Consequently every member of the ultrapower ordinal represented by the constant $\alpha$ is represented by a constant ordinal below $\alpha$. Induction on $\alpha$ now gives $j(\alpha )=\alpha$.

On the other hand the identity function $d(\xi )=\xi$ represents an ordinal below $j(\kappa )$. For every $\alpha <\kappa$, the tail $\{\xi :\xi >\alpha \}$ belongs to $U$, so the collapsed ordinal $[d]$ is above $j(\alpha )=\alpha$. HenceThis proves nonidentity explicitly. The collapsed identity class is at least $\kappa$; it need not equal $\kappa$ unless an additional normality convention is imposed on $U$.

Conversely, an elementary embedding $j:V\to N$ into a transitive class with critical point $\kappa$ yieldsFor the converse use the usual amenability assumption on the class embedding, so this collection is a set. Since $j(\kappa )>\kappa$, exactly one of $j(X)$ and $j(\kappa \setminus X)$ contains $\kappa$, proving the ultrafilter condition. Singletons are excluded because $j(\alpha )=\alpha <\kappa$. If $\lambda <\kappa$ and $X_i\in U$ for $i<\lambda$, then $j$ fixes $\lambda$ and every index below it, giving $j({\bigcap }_{i<\lambda }{X}_i)={\bigcap }_{i<\lambda }j(X_i)$; the intersection still contains $\kappa$. Thus $U$ is $\kappa$-complete and $\kappa$ is measurable.

In particular the first moved ordinal is a strongly inaccessible cardinal. If $\mathrm{cf}(\kappa )<\kappa$, partition $\kappa$ into fewer than $\kappa$ bounded intervals. Each is too small to lie in $U$, contradicting completeness. Thus $\kappa$ is regular. If $2^{\lambda }\ge \kappa$ for some $\lambda <\kappa$, choose distinct subsets $A_{\xi }\subseteq \lambda$ for $\xi <\kappa$. For each $\eta <\lambda$, choose the $U$-large side of the question $\eta \in A_{\xi }$. Intersect these fewer-than-$\kappa$ large sides. The intersection belongs to $U$, but all its indices have identical $A_{\xi }$, so it contains at most one index, contradicting nonprincipality. Therefore $2^{\lambda }<\kappa$ for every $\lambda <\kappa$, as required.