Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2010 / iii / Paper 64 / 3 / Solution

For a nonconstant invasion travelling wave, the relevant end states are $w(-\infty )=k$ and $w(+\infty )=0$. These fronts do not exist at every nonnegative speed: the phase plane calculation gives the threshold $2\sqrt{k}$. The constant solutions $w\equiv 0$ and $w\equiv k$ are, of course, nonnegative travelling waves for every speed, including zero.

Put $z=x-ct$ and $p=w^{\prime }$. The travelling-wave reduction of a reaction-diffusion system givesThe equilibrium points in the phase plane are $(k,0)$ and $(0,0)$. At $(k,0)$ the characteristic equation is $r^2+cr-k=0$, so there is one positive and one negative eigenvalue. Thus it is a saddle equilibrium. Its descending unstable manifold has $w<k$, $p<0$ and locallyAt $(0,0)$ the eigenvalues areFor $c>2\sqrt{k}$ it is a stable node; for $0<c<2\sqrt{k}$ it is a stable spiral. The repeated-root case $c=2\sqrt{k}$ must be included in the existence argument rather than inferred from distinct roots.

Suppose $c\ge 2\sqrt{k}$. Choose $a>0$ with $a(c-a)\ge k$; for example $a=(c-\sqrt{c^2-4k})/2$. Consider the closed triangular regionOn the horizontal side $p=0$, the vector field has $p^{\prime }=-w(k-w)\le 0$, pointing into $\mathcal{T}$. On the vertical side $w=k$, it has $w^{\prime }=p\le 0$, again pointing inward. For the sloping side use $h=p+aw$, so that on $h=0$,Thus trajectories cannot cross into $h<0$. The remaining boundary point $(0,0)$ is an equilibrium point and cannot be crossed in finite time by a nonconstant trajectory, by uniqueness theorem for ordinary differential equations. This proves forward invariance of $\mathcal{T}$. The argument works unchanged at $c=2\sqrt{k}$ with $a=\sqrt{k}$.

The descending unstable manifold of $(k,0)$ initially enters $\mathcal{T}$. Its forward trajectory remains in this compact region, so it exists for all positive $z$. Within the interior, $p<0$: a first contact with $p=0$ at $0<w<k$ would have $p^{\prime }<0$, contrary to arrival from below. Hence $w$ decreases strictly and has a limit $\ell \in [0,k)$. To identify the limit, its omega-limit set lies on the line $w=\ell$ and is invariant. Any trajectory remaining on this line has $p=w^{\prime }=0$; its second equation then forces $\ell (k-\ell )=0$. Since $\ell <k$, it follows that $\ell =0$, and the only possible omega-limit set is $(0,0)$. Backward in $z$, the unstable manifold tends to $(k,0)$ by its construction. We have therefore obtained a positive decreasing heteroclinic orbit and hence a nonnegative travelling wave for every $c\ge 2\sqrt{k}$.

For completeness, the threshold is necessary for such a front. When $0<c<2\sqrt{k}$, put $\nu =\sqrt{k-c^2/4}$, $X=w$, and $Y=(p+cw/2)/\nu$. Near the zero equilibrium point the system becomesFor a nonzero trajectory its polar angle satisfiesA trajectory approaching zero therefore makes infinitely many rotations and must cross $X=w=0$. It cannot be a nonnegative front. At $c=0$, the first integralis conserved. It has values $k^3/6$ and $0$ at the two desired end states, so no heteroclinic orbit connects them. ConsequentlyThis is the phase-plane construction of a Fisher travelling front, including the critical speed. The statement for all $c\ge 0$ must distinguish these nonconstant fronts from the two constant travelling waves.