Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2012 / iii / Paper 3 / 1 / Solution

A partition of an integer $n$ is a finite sequence ${\lambda }_1\ge \cdots \ge {\lambda }_{\ell }>0$ with sum $n$; append zeros when comparing lengths. Its Young diagram has cells $(i,j)$ with $1\le j\le {\lambda }_i$. A Young tableau is a bijective filling of these cells by $1,\dots ,n$. Write $R_t,C_t$ for its row and column stabilizers, and fix the conventionPermutations act on entries on the left, with the rightmost factor acting first. This defines the Young symmetrizer used throughout. In the dictionary order on integer partitions, $\lambda >\mu$ means that at the first differing part ${\lambda }_i>{\mu }_i$; equality is allowed in $\ge$.

Suppose there is no row-column collision between $t$ of shape $\lambda$ and $u$ of shape $\mu$. Each column of $u$ contains at most one entry from each row of $t$. The first $k$ rows of $t$ therefore contain at mostentries, where ${\mu }_j^{\prime }$ is a column length. Thus ${\sum }_{i\le k}{\lambda }_i\le {\sum }_{i\le k}{\mu }_i$ for every $k$: $\mu$ dominates $\lambda$ in dominance order on partitions. If $\lambda \ge \mu$ in dictionary order on integer partitions, a first strictly larger part would contradict the corresponding prefix inequality. Hence $\lambda =\mu$.

All the bounds must now be equalities. Every column $j$ of $u$ contains exactly one entry from row $i$ of $t$ whenever $i\le {\lambda }_j^{\prime }$. Choose $r_0\in R_t$ sending that entry to the entry of $t$ in cell $(i,j)$. These prescriptions are bijections within the rows. The columns of $r_{0}u$ then have exactly the same sets of entries as the columns of $t$, so $r_{0}u=c_{0}t$ for some $c_0\in C_t$. ConsequentlyIf a collision was present instead, its two entries supply the first alternative. This proves the row-column collision lemma, including the prescribed order of the two stabilizer factors.

We next prove the Specht module classification. By Maschke's theorem, the group algebra $A=\mathbb{C}{S}_n$ is a semisimple algebra. Use the permitted basic quasi-idempotence of a Young symmetrizer,and put $e_t=h_t/H_{\lambda }$. The coefficient of $1$ in $h_t$ is one, because $R_t\cap C_t=\{1\}$, so $e_t\ne 0$.

For $\pi \in S_n$, consider $r_t\pi c_t$. A collision between the rows of $t$ and the columns of $\pi t$ gives a transposition $\tau \in R_t\cap \pi C_t{\pi }^{-1}$. Row symmetrization fixes $\tau$, whereas column antisymmetrization changes its sign, so $r_t\pi c_t=0$. If there is no collision, the proved lemma gives $\pi =rc$ with $r\in R_t,c\in C_t$, andIt follows that $h_t\pi h_t$ is zero or $\mathrm{sgn}(c)H_{\lambda }{h}_t$. Since permutations span $A$, $e_{t}A{e}_t=\mathbb{C}{e}_t$. In a semisimple algebra this means that $e_t$ is a primitive idempotent, so $A{e}_t=A{h}_t$ is an irreducible left module.

If $\lambda >\mu$ in dictionary order on integer partitions, the collision lemma applied to every $\pi u$ gives $r_{t}A{c}_u=0$, and therefore $h_{t}A{h}_u=0$. Sincethe two simple modules cannot be isomorphic. Conversely, Young tableaux of the same shape are related by a permutation, which conjugates their Young symmetrizers and gives isomorphic left ideals. Finally, the center of $\mathbb{C}{S}_n$ has the conjugacy-class sums as a basis. Conjugacy classes are indexed by cycle-type partitions, so its dimension is the number of partitions of $n$. The Artin–Wedderburn theorem gives exactly that many simple-module isomorphism classes. We have already produced one for each partition. Thus the $A{h}_{\lambda }$ form a complete set of pairwise nonisomorphic irreducible modules.