Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 22 / 1 / ii

Here is an elementary polynomial pencil with four square members argument. Suppose first that $u,v$ are linearly dependent. Their coprimality of polynomials then forces both to be constant. Otherwise write the four distinct members as $L_j={\alpha }_{j}u+{\beta }_{j}v=s_j^2$. They are nonzero and pairwise coprime polynomials: a common nonconstant factor of two members would divide both $u$ and $v$.

Put $d=\max (\mathrm{deg}u,\mathrm{deg}v)>0$. At most one member of the pencil has degree of a polynomial smaller than $d$, since cancellation of its leading coefficient determines a unique projective pair. Choose a member $L_k$ of minimal degree $e$ and any independent member $L_l$ of degree $d$. The polynomialis nonzero: otherwise the rational function $L_k/L_l$ would have zero derivative, hence would be constant in characteristic zero. Its degree is at most $d+e-1$; if both members have degree zero the original $d>0$ assumption has already failed.

Replacing this pair by any other independent pair changes $W$ only by a nonzero scalar. Since $L_j=s_j^2$, each $s_j$ divides $W$. The pairwise coprimality of polynomials therefore gives ${\prod }_j{s}_j\mid W$. But three members have degree $d$, soa contradiction. Consequently $u$ and $v$ are constant. The possibility that a member is zero was already covered by linear dependence.

To apply this to an elliptic curve, complete the square in its Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve and work over $\mathbb{C}$. Nonsingularity gives three distinct roots $e_1,e_2,e_3$, so the equation becomes $y^2={\prod }_{j=1}^3(x-e_j)$. A nonconstant rational parametrization of an algebraic curve would have $x=u/v$ with coprime polynomials. Clearing denominators givesThe four factors are pairwise coprime polynomials. A rational function whose square is a polynomial is itself a polynomial, by comparing numerator and denominator in lowest terms. Unique factorization, and the fact that every nonzero complex constant has a square root, make each of these four factors a square in $\mathbb{C}[t]$. They correspond to four distinct projective pairs. The result just proved forces $u,v$ to be constant, and the equation then forces $y$ to be constant as well. This proves the nonparametrizability of an elliptic curve.