Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2014 / iii / Paper 57 / 2 / e

The secular gravitational instability needs $|k|<k_{\mathrm{crit}}=2\pi G{\sigma }_0/c^2$. A finite radial extent $L$ removes arbitrarily small wavenumbers; the smallest available one is $k_{\min }\sim \alpha /L$, where $\alpha$ is a boundary-dependent constant of order unity. With $H=c/\Omega$ and the dust Toomre parameter,Thus the finite-size secular gravitational criterion is $\boxed{Q\lesssim L/H}$ at the rough accuracy requested. For example, a periodic radial interval has $k_{\min }=2\pi /L$ and gives $Q<L/(\pi H)$ in this idealized model. The numerical prefactor is not universal, but the scaling is. Finite size therefore restores a practical threshold for the otherwise long-wavelength instability. Growth must additionally occur within the disk lifetime, and a global wavelength comparable to disk radius lies beyond the strictly local shearing sheet approximation.