Past exam of the quantum condensed matter course of the University of Cambridge / 2008 / Section B / B1 / b / Solution

Put $N=N_x{N}_y{N}_z$ primitive cells in a periodic box. In each reciprocal-space direction, the allowed Bloch wavevectors are spaced by $2\pi /L_i$, giving $N_i$ independent values in the first Brillouin zone. There are consequently $N$ wavevectors per band and, including two electron spin states at each wavevector,The total and per-atom counts are different; a factor $N$ cannot remain in the per-atom count for this monatomic lattice.

In independent-electron band theory, a partially occupied band permits low-energy changes of occupancy and gives a metal. Filled bands separated from empty bands by a finite band gap give a band insulator at zero temperature. An odd number of electrons per primitive cell cannot fill spin-degenerate bands, whereas an even number can; even filling alone does not ensure an insulator if bands overlap. Magnetic symmetry breaking and strong correlations, such as a Mott insulator, go beyond this simple counting criterion.