Past exam of the year 2 of the earth sciences (geology) course of the University of Oxford / 2023 / Paper 1 / 2 / d / Solution

The reverse fault requires strong east–west compression; the vertical opening geological joints require the least principal stress in the effective stress tensor east–west. They need not have formed at the same time or under the same local stress field. Compression can form the reverse fault during burial and crustal shortening; subsequent tectonic exhumation, unloading, relaxation, cooling or another tectonic episode can rotate the principal stress ordering and permit opening geological joints.

Furthermore, local stress near faults, layer interfaces and topography can differ from the regional stress. A high pore pressure shifts every Mohr circle left by $p$, helping tensile failure, but isotropic pore pressure alone cannot exchange the east–west and vertical principal stress ordering. Determine relative timing using cross-cutting relations, offsets of geological joints, and any generations of fracture-filling minerals. Spatial coexistence is therefore evidence of a deformation history, rather than a requirement that the two failure diagrams describe one simultaneous homogeneous stress state.