Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 iii Paper 54 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
At the usual two-derivative order, the two-derivative global supersymmetric gauge action isHere is the chiral field-strength superfield, distinguished from the superpotential . The Kähler potential is a real gauge-invariant function, defined up to a Kähler transformation; supplies the scalar kinetic metric. The superpotential is a gauge-invariant holomorphic function of the chiral superfields. The symmetric gauge kinetic function is holomorphic and transforms so that its contraction with the field strengths is gauge invariant. Its real part supplies the gauge and gaugino kinetic coefficients and must be positive on physical configurations; its imaginary part supplies the topological angle. The final constants are Fayet–Iliopoulos terms, normalized so that they contribute when has highest component .
For the simple non-Abelian gauge group specified in the question, . Invariance of a proposed requires . A simple Lie algebra equals its commutator algebra, so no nonzero invariant covector exists. This proves that Fayet–Iliopoulos terms require an Abelian gauge factor. The last term above describes the customary Abelian extension, not an additional arbitrary coupling of the simple group.
For a renormalizable theory, after choosing matter bases the functions reduce toOnly gauge-invariant monomials are included. A nonconstant would produce interactions of dimension greater than four. Here the gauge coupling is absorbed into the connection in , while in the holomorphic normalization. A constant has no dynamical effect in global supersymmetry. The original arbitrary functions remain useful for a nonrenormalizable two-derivative effective theory, but the following argument restricts to the requested renormalizable setting.
To analyze perturbative corrections, use a local Wilsonian effective action with a nonzero infrared cutoff and keep the same elementary fields. Introduce nondynamical background chiral superfields into its F-term part:One may additionally promote each polynomial coefficient to its own chiral spurion to track flavor charges. Treating the couplings as fields ensures that a local chiral integral depends holomorphically on : antichiral dependence would violate the chirality constraint unless accompanied by derivatives or rewritten as a D-term. This is the key use of holomorphy, rather than an assumption that all effective-action terms are holomorphic.
Give R-charge one, the matter fields charge zero, charge two and charge zero. Then the chiral measure has charge minus two, has charge two, and has charge one. These assignments define formal spurionic symmetries even if fixed numerical couplings do not enjoy the corresponding physical symmetry. An anomalous transformation is accompanied by the appropriate shift of the gauge-coupling spurion; nonperturbative dependence can record that anomaly.
For the superpotential non-renormalization argument, perturbation theory is insensitive to continuous shifts of the topological angle, which shifts the imaginary part of . A holomorphic coefficient invariant under every such shift is independent of by the Cauchy-Riemann equations. This proves perturbative gauge-coupling independence of the Wilsonian superpotential. At fixed infrared cutoff the perturbative expansion is regular near zero superpotential couplings. R-charge two therefore forces an allowed correction to be linear in , rather than involving , or inverse powers of . Flavor charges impose the corresponding monomial selection rules.
The remaining coefficient can be evaluated at zero gauge coupling. Free chiral propagators join a chiral and an antichiral endpoint. A single holomorphic superpotential vertex cannot close a loop; adding antichiral vertices violates holomorphy, while adding holomorphic vertices violates the linear spurion degree. Consequently the coefficient is its tree value. This proves, rather than merely quotes, the perturbative resultThe fixed-cutoff regularity matters: integrating out a whole massive multiplet can introduce inverse masses at tree level, and infrared-singular one-particle-irreducible expressions are not this local Wilsonian superpotential.
For the gauge kinetic function, R-charge zero excludes regular positive powers of in its perturbative coefficient. Flavor spurions cannot repair this without forbidden antichiral or singular dependence. A topological-angle shift changes the tree gauge term only by its topological contribution, so the correction is invariant under the shift. Holomorphy then makes it independent of . An -loop correction to the inverse gauge coupling carries the weak-coupling behavior : only one loop has the required coupling-independent behavior. Hence the one-loop exactness of the holomorphic gauge kinetic function givesup to a one-loop matching constant. The coefficient follows from the usual one-loop field contributions: gauge bosons and an adjoint Weyl gaugino contribute , while a chiral Weyl fermion and complex scalar contribute . Holomorphic logarithmic thresholds appear when massive fields are eliminated. This statement is about the holomorphic Wilsonian coupling, not a canonically normalized physical gauge coupling, whose running need not be one-loop exact.
The Kähler potential is integrated over all of superspace. It can depend on , on both and , and on both matter chiralities. These neutral combinations allow ordinary loop corrections, such as a Yukawa-dependent correction to , and no analogous argument forbids higher loops. ThusIts wave-function renormalization changes physical superpotential couplings after canonical normalization even though holomorphic vertex coefficients do not change. For a single field with kinetic coefficient , for instance, and .
Finally consider perturbative renormalization of a Fayet–Iliopoulos term in an Abelian extension. A term must be invariant under for arbitrary chiral . Projection of the variation requires . An arbitrary algebraic function of background chiral spurions and their conjugates fails this requirement unless it is constant. Therefore a general coupling-dependent local FI counterterm is forbidden. The one-loop tadpole from charged scalars can still giveIt is independent of interaction couplings in the connection normalization used above and proportional to the trace of the Abelian charge generator. Higher-loop diagrams require interactions and cannot produce the permitted coupling-independent additive term. Thus a traceless Abelian charge generator has no additive perturbative FI renormalization in this exactly supersymmetric setting; otherwise a one-loop, regulator-dependent tadpole is possible. Vector-field normalization can change the reported canonical parameter, and soft breaking falls outside this proof. For the specified simple group, gauge invariance forbids before and after corrections.
These are perturbative statements. Instantons or other nonperturbative effects may produce symmetry-allowed holomorphic terms, for example dependence on , so neither the superpotential result nor the one-loop gauge result should be misread as forbidding all nonperturbative corrections.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2008 iii Paper 53 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Work with a supersymmetry-preserving regulator and a local Wilsonian effective action at a nonzero infrared cutoff, in holomorphic field variables. Its two-derivative terms have the formHere is the gauge field-strength superfield, distinct from the superpotential , and the gauge kinetic function is symmetric and holomorphic. The perturbative non-renormalization theorem statesThe same elementary light fields are retained in the first equality. It does not prohibit tree-level changes to the superpotential when an entire massive field is eliminated. The Kähler potential may be renormalized at every loop order, nonperturbative effects are separate, and canonically normalized physical couplings need not satisfy these holomorphic statements.
First prove superpotential non-renormalization. Promote every coupling in to a background chiral superfield, or spurion. A local F-term must remain chiral for arbitrary backgrounds, so its coefficient is holomorphic in and the , not in their complex conjugates. Give the matter superfields formal R-charge zero, charge one, and every charge two. The superpotential then has charge two. A perturbative term regular when the interactions vanish must be linear in the holomorphic superpotential couplings: a product of two or more has too large an R-charge, and antichiral couplings cannot compensate it. Formal gauge anomalies of this transformation are accounted for by the transformation of the holomorphic gauge coupling; they are not silently assumed absent.
The remaining possible coefficient cannot receive gauge-dependent perturbative corrections. The holomorphic gauge coupling may be written . Perturbation theory is insensitive to the topological angle, so any ordinary superpotential coefficient is invariant under , with real . A holomorphic function with this continuous imaginary-shift invariance is constant in by the Cauchy-Riemann equations. This is perturbative gauge-coupling independence of the Wilsonian superpotential.
We can consequently evaluate the surviving term with the gauge interaction turned off. A single holomorphic interaction vertex is the tree superpotential vertex. It cannot make a loop using free - propagators without additional vertices and antichiral couplings. Such couplings are excluded by holomorphy, and extra holomorphic vertices are excluded by the spurion degree. With the infrared cutoff retained, propagators and interactions can be expanded with masses treated as insertions, so infrared-singular inverse-mass exceptions are not part of this regular perturbative argument. The coefficient must therefore equal its tree value. This proves the spurion selection rule for perturbative non-renormalization for arbitrary superpotential monomials.
Now prove one-loop exactness of the holomorphic gauge kinetic function. Add an independent constant background coupling to the gauge kinetic function. An imaginary shift changes the action only by the topological density, whose perturbative normalization is fixed. Thus the holomorphic perturbative coefficient transforms asDifferentiating with respect to gives . Therefore the correction is independent of ; nonlinear inverse powers of cannot be holomorphic shift-invariant corrections. The gauge coefficient has R-charge zero, so its regular perturbative correction also cannot contain positive powers of the charge-two superpotential spurions. The anomalous shift of accounts for the allowed one-loop anomaly; it does not permit arbitrary higher-loop spurion dependence.
To connect this constraint to loop order, use gauge fields whose bare kinetic term has coefficient . After factoring this tree normalization, an -loop gauge-kinetic correction scales as . Equivalently, a gauge propagator contributes and a pure-gauge vertex contributes ; with no superpotential interactions, closed matter lines give equal numbers of matter propagators and matter vertices. The connected graph identity then gives for the gauge coefficient. Tree order is linear in , one loop is independent of , and every higher loop has forbidden inverse-coupling dependence. Holomorphy and the spurion constraint exclude additional Yukawa-dependent higher-loop terms. Applying the same background-field reasoning on a nonsingular patch yields the statement for holomorphic field-dependent gauge coefficients; one-loop holomorphic threshold determinants are allowed. Thus the only perturbative correction to is the one-loop correction.
For one simple gauge factor with , the one-loop beta function of a supersymmetric gauge theory has . The vector and adjoint Weyl contributions give , while one matter Weyl fermion and complex scalar contribute . Consequently, away from thresholds,This sign makes the real inverse coupling decrease toward the infrared in an asymptotically free theory.
Finally, holomorphic and canonically normalized superpotential couplings are different. For example, if , then changes to coefficients and . They run even though the original holomorphic coefficients have no vertex corrections. Gauge-field and matter-field rescalings likewise distinguish the physical gauge coupling from the Wilsonian holomorphic one, allowing higher-loop physical running. Infrared-singular terms in a one-particle-irreducible action cannot be substituted for a local Wilsonian term. Nonperturbative terms such as evade continuous topological-angle shift invariance and may generate superpotentials or gauge-kinetic effects when the symmetries and dynamics permit them. These qualifications are essential to the theorem's statement.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 307 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The renormalizable action for chiral superfields and vector superfields has the superspace integration formwhere is a real Kähler potential, is the chiral field-strength superfield, and is a gauge-invariant holomorphic function. For the renormalizable theory choose canonical positive kinetic terms, a polynomial of degree at most three, and field-independent gauge kinetic coefficients . We prove the non-renormalization theorem for the local Wilsonian effective action, with a nonzero infrared cutoff and a regulator preserving supersymmetry. The elementary chiral superfields are retained; this is not a claim that eliminating whole massive fields leaves the same polynomial.
Write , treating masses and interaction coefficients alike as background chiral spurions. A local F-term is chiral even when these backgrounds vary, so its coefficient depends holomorphically on and the holomorphic gauge couplings. Dependence on would not be chiral. Such dependence can enter D-terms or terms with supercovariant derivatives instead. With the infrared cutoff kept fixed, the perturbative local coefficients are regular power series around vanishing masses and interactions. This removes the inverse-mass and infrared singular terms that would spoil the following spurion selection rule for perturbative non-renormalization.
Assign every elementary R-charge zero, every R-charge two, and R-charge one. The superpotential must have R-charge two because has R-charge minus two. Holomorphy excludes the conjugate spurions, so regularity and this formal R-symmetry require exactly one factor of a superpotential spurion in any perturbative candidate. Thus is linear in the , with the ordinary flavor spurion charges fixing the permitted field monomials. An anomalous formal R-symmetry is implemented by also transforming the holomorphic gauge coupling; its anomaly must not simply be ignored.
Gauge interactions cannot provide a perturbative coefficient modifying this conclusion. With , perturbative diagrams are independent of the topological angle . A holomorphic coefficient invariant under continuous real shifts of is constant, by the Cauchy-Riemann equations. This is perturbative gauge-coupling independence of the Wilsonian superpotential. Contributions involving are nonperturbative and are outside this argument. For an Abelian factor the same angle-independent holomorphy argument applies. Hence a putative perturbative coefficient linear in is independent of the gauge coupling and can be evaluated as that coupling tends to zero.
In this free-gauge limit, an interacting chiral loop needs additional superpotential vertices: the free chiral propagator connects to , so a single holomorphic vertex alone cannot produce a loop correcting its local F-term. Extra vertices introduce extra spurions or their conjugates, both excluded by the preceding charge and holomorphy argument. The surviving coefficient is its tree value. Therefore
For an explicit charge check, take in the Wess–Zumino model. Give ordinary charges and R-charges . A holomorphic monomial of the required charges satisfies and , giving , . Perturbative regularity requires , hence only and survive. The free limit fixes their coefficients to and ; there is no room for a coupling-dependent loop correction. This illustrates the holomorphy argument for superpotential non-renormalization explicitly.
The Kähler potential can acquire wave-function renormalization. Restoring canonical field normalization changes physical masses and Yukawa couplings, so their running does not contradict the boxed statement about holomorphic coordinates. Gauge kinetic F-terms have their own renormalization and are not the superpotential. Infrared effects in the one-particle-irreducible quantum effective action, tree-level elimination of retained fields, and genuine nonperturbative effects must likewise be distinguished from this perturbative Wilsonian effective action theorem.
Spurion selection rule for perturbative non-renormalization Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-07
In the local Wilsonian effective action, retain the elementary chiral superfields and a nonzero infrared cutoff. Promote each coefficient in to a chiral spurion. Holomorphy excludes . Assigning and forces a regular perturbative term of R-charge two to be linear in these spurions. Ordinary flavor charges constrain its field monomial. The perturbative gauge-coupling independence of the Wilsonian superpotential removes gauge-dependent coefficients. With the gauge coupling zero, a single holomorphic vertex cannot close a loop through free - propagators; extra vertices would violate the spurion degree or holomorphy. Its coefficient is therefore the tree coefficient. Gauge anomalies of the formal R-symmetry are tracked by a transforming holomorphic gauge coupling. Keeping the infrared cutoff matters: singular one-particle-irreducible terms and elimination of entire massive fields are different operations.
The background-field holomorphy method is discussed in Seiberg's non-renormalization paper.