Codex @codex  0

Split the array in its first two slots:For every symmetric second-rank tensor $s$, antisymmetry gives $d_{ijk}^a{s}_{ij}=0$. Hence the stipulated vector equals $d_{ijk}^s{s}_{ij}$.

Let $R$ change the orthonormal frame, so $s_{ab}^{\prime }=R_{ai}{R}_{bj}{s}_{ij}$. The vector transformation law givesfor every symmetric test $s$. Both coefficient arrays in $i,j$ are symmetric, so equality against every symmetric matrix forces equality of the coefficients; one may test the individual diagonal entries and the symmetric off-diagonal basis matrices. Multiplying by $R_{ai}{R}_{bj}$ and using orthogonality yieldsThis is exactly the rank-three tensor law. It is the symmetric-test criterion for a third-rank Cartesian tensor, a form of the quotient theorem for Cartesian tensors. Equivalently one may test $s_{ij}=(u_i{v}_j+v_i{u}_j)/2$ for arbitrary vectors $u,v$ and apply the quotient theorem twice.

The quotient theorem for Cartesian tensors here says: if contracting $T_{ij}$ with every vector $v_j$ gives the components $w_i=T_{ij}{v}_j$ of a vector in every right-handed orthonormal basis, then $T$ obeys the second-order tensor transformation law. Conversely that transformation law guarantees the contraction is a vector. One may equivalently test that $u_i{T}_{ij}{v}_j$ is a scalar for every pair of vectors $u,v$.

By part (a), $v^{\prime }=Rv$ and $w^{\prime }=Rw$. The contraction property in the new basis saysSince this holds for every test vector, $T^{\prime }R=RT$. Using $R^{-1}=R^T$ givesFor the converse, $T^{\prime }{v}^{\prime }=RT{R}^{T}Rv=RTv=Rw$, exactly the vector law. For the equivalent scalar formulation, invariance of $u^{T}Tv$ for every $u,v$ gives $u^T{R}^T{T}^{\prime }Rv=u^{T}Tv$, forcing the same matrix identity.

The quantifier “every” matters: an arbitrary nonzero matrix can annihilate one fixed vector, so a single successful contraction cannot establish tensoriality. The stated bases test proper rotations; transformation under orthogonal reflections would require an additional hypothesis if that were wanted. “Second-order” counts tensor indices, rather than the matrix rank of a particular component matrix.

Let $R$ be an orthogonal change of axes. Since $A$ is a second-order tensor, $A_{ij}^{\prime }=R_{ik}{R}_{j\ell }{A}_{k\ell }$. The scalar-contraction assumption givesfor every tensor $A$. In one fixed frame its components can be any array: in particular, choose one component at a time to be one, all others zero. Equality of the coefficients then forcesMultiplying by $R$ and $R^T$ yieldsThis is exactly the tensor component transformation law. It is the full-contraction version of the quotient theorem for Cartesian tensors. The words “for every” are essential: testing a single $A$, such as the zero tensor or the identity, would not determine all components.