Idempotent ideal 2026-10-06
An ideal is idempotent when . Then for every , so a nonzero idempotent ideal gives a nonzero intersection of all its powers. A semigroup algebra with arbitrarily divisible positive exponents supplies examples in a non-Noetherian integral domain. If is finitely generated, the determinant trick applied to produces such that .
The Artin-Rees lemma states that, for a Noetherian ring , an ideal , a finitely generated module , and a submodule , there is such that
Thus the filtration on induced from the I-adic filtration of is eventually determined by one of its terms.
For the proof, form the Rees ring and its Rees module:
Since is a Noetherian ring, write . Then , so it is a Noetherian ring by the Hilbert basis theorem. Generators of in degree zero generate as a module over , so this is a Noetherian module.
The graded submodule
is therefore finitely generated. Choose homogeneous generators with for some . For , taking degree- components gives
The same generators show that the final sum is exactly . This proves the Artin-Rees lemma. If , one may simply take .
Now let
It is a submodule of the Noetherian module , hence a finitely generated module. Apply the Artin-Rees lemma with and . Since is contained in every (including ), its conclusion reduces to
Write generators as . There is a matrix with entries in such that . Multiplication by the adjugate of shows that
The determinant is congruent to modulo , so it is for some . This determinant trick produces a single such element annihilating all of , and in particular annihilating each . If , use .
Conversely, if with , then . Iterating gives for every . Hence the exact description is
In a local ring with contained in the maximal ideal, every is a unit, so this also yields the usual vanishing form of the Krull intersection theorem.
For a failure without the Noetherian ring hypothesis, let and use the semigroup algebra
Its elements are finite sums of formal monomials , with multiplication . Each ring in the union is a polynomial ring and the inclusions are injective, so is an integral domain. It is not a Noetherian ring, since
Indeed the generator on the left is the square of the next generator, while division in the opposite direction would require a negative exponent, which is unavailable in .
Let be the ideal of elements with zero constant term, equivalently
It is proper because taking the constant term gives . Every generator is , with , so . Thus this is a nonzero idempotent ideal, with for every . Take
For every , the constant term of is , so . Since is an integral domain and , we have . This gives all three requested objects and proves that no element of the required form annihilates .