Double substitution weighing 2026-11-05
Double substitution weighing determines the difference between an unknown mass and a reference through repeated substitutions on the same comparator, with a small known sensitivity mass used to determine response under load. NIST's SOP4 compares standard and unknown twice, rather than relying on the balance to establish their entire masses from its zero.[ref]
Weighing by Double Substitution by National Institute of Standards and Technology. SOP4–2019, p1, Purpose; p3, Summary
For the source's sequence A, let S denote the standard, X the unknown and sw the added sensitivity mass. With optional tare masses omitted, the four pan loads areproducing measurement indications . The standard remains the reference; the small addition probes transducer sensitivity close to the actual working load.[ref]
An original simplified model neglects buoyancy, tare differences and drift, and assumes a common linear response coefficient . Write and for the added mass. Relative to the standard load, the readings areThe two comparison differences estimate the same quantity; averaging them gives . The sensitivity step is , soFor original and readings , this gives . The offset and the unknown response coefficient cancel under the model.
Practical weighing records timing and environmental conditions, keeps settings fixed through the comparison, and controls handling and equilibration. The full NIST procedure supplies buoyancy corrections, uncertainty contributions and a comparison using a check standard.[ref]
Weighing by Double Substitution by National Institute of Standards and Technology. pp2–4, conditions and apparatus; pp7–10, observations, check standard and calculations
For equally spaced readings, a linear additive drift cancels from , but can still affect the sensitivity step . Neither the simplified equation nor the method's name guarantees immunity to drift, contamination, nonlinear response or uncertainty in the measurement standard.