Use the usual nondegenerate positive-rate case , , . Define the Black-Scholes equation
The American value dominates immediate exercise. Its discounted value is a supermartingale under the risk-neutral measure, so , with equality where it is optimal to continue. The obstacle problem is
Equivalently .
For the put, write the exercise boundary as . On solve ; on set . Value matching and smooth pasting require
The remaining conditions are , as , and the terminal contingent claim payoff, with in this positive-rate setting. The boundary is an unknown to be found with the price, which is what makes this a free boundary problem.
An American option allows exercise at a stopping time . For its exercise financial payoff , the pricing problem is
The discounted value is the Snell envelope of discounted exercise payoffs. Define the pricing operator
In the continuation region the Black-Scholes equation holds, . In the exercise region , while the ability to wait and the supermartingale property give . Together these conditions are the obstacle problem
Thus an unknown exercise boundary must be found alongside the value. At a regular boundary in the nondegenerate Itô diffusion, value matching is , and smooth pasting is where the financial payoff is differentiable. A finite difference method or a binomial options pricing model steps backward taking the larger of continuation and immediate exercise values at each node.
For a non-dividend-paying American call option with , no early exercise of a call without dividends follows directly from the European lower bound
At every candidate exercise time, keeping the European call has value at least the immediate exercise financial payoff, so early exercise cannot improve the value; the American and European prices coincide. The first inequality follows from Jensen inequality or put-call parity and nonnegative put value. With an American put option can benefit from early receipt of its strike at sufficiently low stock prices, so its exercise boundary is generally nontrivial and its value is at least the European put value. Dividends can make call exercise worthwhile, and negative interest invalidates the stated no-early-exercise call argument.