Strict positivity without coercivity can fail variational solvability

On l2 sequence space ${\ell }^2$, let $(Lu{)}_n=u_n/n$ and $f_n=1/n$. This bounded self-adjoint operator has $⟨Lu,u⟩>0$ for nonzero $u$, but the equation $Lu=f$ requires $u_n=1$, which is not in ${\ell }^2$. Taking the first $N$ coordinates equal to one makes $I(u)=-{\sum }_{n=1}^{N}1/n\to -\infty$. Thus strict positivity in isolation does not give existence in that Hilbert space; a coercive bilinear form and a continuous forcing functional in its norm are essential hypotheses for the usual minimization proof.