Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 9 3 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
The function is strictly increasing on and strictly decreasing on . Hence for each there is a unique with .
Apply the subcritical component estimates to . For a specified vertex, the exact tree-component expectation in the Erdős-Rényi model gives the limiting probability that it lies in a tree component of order :For each fixed , the probability of a non-tree graph component of that size is : a spanning tree and one extra edge are necessary. Moreover the Galton-Watson process exploration estimate from the preceding proof bounds the probability of order greater than by , uniformly in , where . First let for fixed , then let . No probability mass escapes to large components or non-tree components, so . Multiplying by and using its defining identity givesEquivalently, the rooted-tree generating function selects the smaller solution of . The choice of that branch is essential; the larger solution is not the value of this convergent series.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 9 3 i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Assume , as required for this nontrivial subcritical binomial random graph. Put . A breadth-first exploration of a binomial random graph is dominated by a Galton-Watson process whose offspring counts are independent random variables with law . If its total progeny is at least , the first offspring counts sum to at least . Their moment-generating function is bounded by that of a Poisson distribution of mean . The exponential Markov inequality, optimized at , yieldsTaking for any fixed , a union bound over all starting vertices gives .
For the matching lower bound, let count tree components of order . The tree-component expectation in the Erdős-Rényi model is exactlyFor , the Stirling formula givesChoose , with . Then . Distinct overlapping vertex sets cannot both be graph components. For disjoint sets, the joint probability differs from the product only because the between-set edges were counted twice as absent. ThusIt follows that . The second moment method gives with high probability. Combining both bounds, and then taking arbitrarily small fixed , proves the sharp subcritical largest-component scaleFinally the Taylor expansion of gives . The endpoint has no edges and is excluded from this logarithmic asymptotic.
Rooted-tree generating function 2026-10-07
The exponential generating function for labelled rooted trees satisfies : remove the root and obtain an unordered set of smaller labelled rooted trees. For , the convergent series is the solution in of , rather than the larger real solution. Alternatively, tree-component expectation in the Erdős-Rényi model and subcritical exploration give for : their limiting probabilities for the order of the tree component of a uniform vertex sum to one. The component tail bound makes this passage through the infinite sum valid.
Sharp subcritical largest-component scale 2026-10-07
For fixed in , the largest component of a graph has the displayed order with high probability. A dominating Galton-Watson process gives the tail bound by the exponential Markov inequality. For the lower bound, the tree-component expectation in the Erdős-Rényi model diverges at . The disjoint-set covariance factor and the exclusion of overlaps give relative variance tending to zero, so the second moment method supplies a tree component of that order.