Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2010 iii Paper 19 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Retain and define the heat operator by . A Riemannian heat kernel satisfies for and has the delta initial limitOn standard Euclidean space the kernel isOn the Riemannian manifold, the Gaussian function factor in the local construction uses in place of .
Choose an open neighbourhood of the diagonal such that every pair is joined by a unique short minimizing geodesic and with the inverse exponential map smooth in both variables. It can be obtained from normal coordinates tubes of radius smaller than the local injectivity radius, or from normal neighbourhoods with geodesic convexity. Then is smooth on . Write the Riemannian volume form in normal coordinates as , where is smooth and .
For fixed , radial divergence in normal coordinates givesFor , use away from the diagonal and the product rule to obtainThe identities extend smoothly in the expressions involving , even though itself is not smooth on the diagonal. The singular powers cancel ifThe correct initial normalization is . These heat-kernel transport equations have the explicit solutionsand, recursively,To derive the integral, multiply the radial equation by and integrate the derivative of from zero to . The zero integration constant is forced by smoothness when . Changing variables from radial distance to gives the displayed nonsingular expression. Its integrand is smooth in , so differentiation under the integral proves inductively that every is smooth across the diagonal. In particular .
Summing the product-rule identity makes adjacent terms telescope. For , the only term remaining isThis also fixes the sign convention: with the nonnegative Laplace-Beltrami operator , the right-hand side would instead be .
A heat parametrix is an approximate kernel with the same delta initial limit and an error under that is sufficiently regular, or flat, at to be corrected by time convolution. On a closed compact manifold choose a smooth cutoff equal to one near the diagonal and supported in . A finite-order explicit parametrix isNear the diagonal its error is . Derivatives of produce errors supported a positive distance from the diagonal, where decays faster than every power of . Taking large makes the whole error as regular at time zero as any specified finite number of derivatives requires. Its initial delta limit follows from and the Euclidean Gaussian function change of variables .
One may obtain a smooth error flat at zero by summing all coefficients with time cutoffs. Let equal one near zero and zero for arguments at least one, and choose sufficiently fast. SetFor each the sum is locally finite. Choosing successively so that the th term and its derivatives through order have bounds on their cutoff transition regions gives the usual smooth asymptotic sum. For any fixed derivative order, its tail is then smaller than an arbitrarily high power of ; the transport identities cancel all earlier orders. Consequently extends smoothly and flatly to .
Here is the Volterra parametrix correction, with the order of the Volterra convolution of kernels factors specified. DefineSince acts in the second spatial variable and has the delta initial limit, . ThusIndeed, by the geometric-series cancellation, whence . If on a bounded time interval and , thenThis proves convergence; the smooth flat error permits the corresponding derivative estimates. The correction has zero initial limit, so retains the delta initial condition. Uniqueness of the heat equation on a closed compact manifold identifies this kernel with the global Riemannian heat kernel.
The local coefficient construction requires no compactness. The global uniformly bounded convolution argument just given uses a closed compact manifold, the usual spectral-geometry setting. For noncompact or incomplete Riemannian manifolds one must specify the heat realization and justify global convergence separately; a canonical choice is the minimal kernel obtained as the increasing limit of Dirichlet kernels on a smooth relatively compact exhaustion. This gives the minimal heat semigroup rather than asserting an unqualified uniqueness statement at infinity or at a missing boundary.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 16 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Let be a closed manifold with a Riemannian metric and use , the positive Laplace-Beltrami operator. This is the setting in which the final discrete eigenfunction expansion applies without additional boundary or noncompact spectral hypotheses. A Riemannian heat kernel is a smooth for such thatfor every smooth initial function . Here solves the heat equation. The limit is the statement that the initial kernel is the Dirac delta distribution on the diagonal. In the closed setting this uniquely determines the heat kernel; it is symmetric, preserves constants, is nonnegative, and satisfies the semigroup property.
A heat parametrix is an approximate version with the same delta initial limit and with errorregular enough at to correct by a convergent integral series. One may construct it by the local Gaussian ansatzwhere near the diagonal and is supported in a convex normal neighborhood, and the smooth coefficients solve the usual radial transport equations. The leading coefficient accounts for the Riemannian volume form. Taking sufficiently large makes the residual extend continuously, with any prescribed finite number of derivatives, to . Alternatively a smooth asymptotic summation of all transport coefficients gives a residual vanishing to every order. These local construction, extension and differentiability facts are used here as subsidiary results, as permitted.
For the correction proof take a heat parametrix whose residual is smooth up to on a short interval . We also use its uniform integral bound , its approximate-identity limit, and the following standard differentiability property: convolution with a smooth time-dependent kernel gives a smooth kernel for , and differentiating it yields the identity below. These properties follow from the Gaussian estimates and the delta initial limit; no conclusion about the final exact heat kernel is assumed.
Define the Volterra convolution of kernels byIt is associative wherever these integrals converge. The delta term at the upper endpoint givesSeek . Then its error vanishes exactly when . The solution is the Volterra parametrix correctionThe signs matter: the first correction is .
To prove convergence, let and . The time variables in range over a simplex of volume , soThe series for therefore converges uniformly on . Derivatives obey analogous bounds, with polynomial factors in , by the quoted residual extension and differentiation properties. Thus the series can be convolved and differentiated as above. Associativity and absolute convergence give , proving . The correction has integral norm by the integral bound on and boundedness of . It has zero initial limit, so has precisely the required delta initial data.
For uniqueness, a smooth solution with zero initial data satisfies the heat equation energy identityIts initial norm is zero, hence . Applying uniqueness to consecutive evolutions proves the semigroup property. Choose and, for arbitrary , compose enough kernels that . The resulting kernel is independent of the subdivision by uniqueness, is smooth for positive time by the quoted differentiability property, and extends the construction to every . This proves a parametrix determines the global heat kernel in the closed setting. The heat equation maximum principle gives nonnegativity and applying uniqueness to the constant initial function gives conservation of total mass. Self-adjointness of the positive Laplace-Beltrami operator gives symmetry.
Finally let be a complete complex orthonormal eigenbasis of , with eigenvalues , repeated by multiplicity. As subsidiary analytic facts we use the compact elliptic compact elliptic spectral theorem, elliptic regularity bounds making each fixed derivative of grow at most polynomially in , and a polynomial eigenvalue-counting bound. The spectral expansion of the Riemannian heat kernel converges because exponential decay makes the following series converge with every derivative when :Indeed, evolving initial data gives by direct substitution into the heat equation and uniqueness. For general , completeness and the heat equation energy identity giveThe smoothly convergent kernel series represents this same operator, and equality for all smooth identifies it pointwise with the constructed heat kernel. The complex conjugate is required by the inner product; for a real eigenbasis it may be omitted. A noncompact Riemannian manifold may instead require a spectral integral, and the unqualified discrete formula should not be asserted there.
Volterra parametrix correction Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-14
If is smooth and bounded up to time zero on a closed manifold, the Volterra convolution of kernels solves by . Bounds by prove convergence. Then is the exact Riemannian heat kernel and has the same initial delta limit.