Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 iii Paper 8 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For the Volterra integration operator, Cauchy-Schwarz inequality givesIntegrating and reversing the order yieldsThus is bounded, with . Since , is absolutely continuous and almost everywhere. If as an element, its continuous representative is zero everywhere, so its derivative is zero almost everywhere. Hence is one-to-one.
Its range is exactly , and . This contains the smooth compactly supported functions in , so is a densely defined operator. Closedness can also be seen directly: if and in , then , giving and .
For every ,If , the allowed fact makes invertible. At , is invertible too. Thus the bounded operatorhas range in and is a two-sided inverse of . Equivalently, solving the initial-value differential equation givesThis is bounded for every fixed on the finite interval. Therefore Volterra inverse differentiation has empty spectrum:The familiar nonempty-spectrum theorem for bounded operators does not apply to this unbounded operator.
The subspace is the kernel of the bounded functional , so it is closed. Its image under isthe zero-trace Sobolev space. If , and , then converges to , and . Thus is closed. It is densely defined because it also contains the smooth compactly supported functions.
For any , the same formula gives , with no endpoint term because vanishes there. Consequently and , proving the requested inclusion. In fact, testing against compactly supported smooth shows that every element of has weak derivative in ; conversely the integration-by-parts formula applies to every . Thuswith no boundary restrictions.
For any , the nonzero function belongs to this domain and satisfies . Conversely this first-order equation has only scalar multiples of that exponential. ThereforeFor any , the adjoint eigenfunction with eigenvalue annihilates , so this range is not all of . Explicitly the resolvent equation with zero initial value has the solution above, and its endpoint value is zero exactly whenThus the range is a proper closed hyperplane for every . This proves that the two-endpoint symmetric derivative has whole complex spectrum:There are no eigenvalues of itself: the eigenfunction equation together with forces the exponential coefficient to vanish. The operator is symmetric but not self-adjoint, since its adjoint has a strictly larger domain; symmetry alone does not force a real spectrum.