 Solution

The relevant competition is between energy reduction and magnetic flux freezing. Ideal evolution transports the entire connectivity of the magnetic field lines, including the separation and linkage of flux regions. Viscous dissipation can remove kinetic energy but cannot permit magnetic reconnection between such regions. As each region relaxes toward lower magnetic energy, neighboring flux regions can approach with different limiting tangential fields. A smooth transition can become increasingly thin; its field remains bounded while its curl, and therefore its electric current density, becomes large.

The limiting object is a current sheet. If $\mathbf{n}$ points from its minus to its plus side, its surface electric current density isFor a tangential discontinuity, ${\mathbf{B}}_{\pm }\cdot \mathbf{n}=0$. The normal balance in magnetostatic equilibrium requiresThus a finite jump of tangential field can coexist with equilibrium: the jump of magnetic pressure is balanced by the ordinary pressure jump.

This need not happen for every initial field; a field already in smooth magnetostatic equilibrium is an immediate exception. The expectation concerns topology-constrained relaxation for which a smooth limiting arrangement is obstructed. Current-sheet formation is consistent with the relaxation framework developed in Moffatt's primary analysis. Retaining complete frozen connectivity is essential; minimizing energy subject only to the value of total magnetic helicity would generally permit field rearrangements forbidden by this evolution.