 Solution

The concavity inequality is true, but its printed equality condition is false. At $b=1$ equality always holds, even for distinct states; for example take ${\rho }_1=|0⟩⟨0|$ and ${\rho }_2=|1⟩⟨1|$. The correct statement on $0\le b\le 1$ isFor $0<b<1$, entropy is therefore strictly concave.

We give the matrix inequality needed for the proof. Define the quantum relative entropy $D(\tau \Vert \sigma )=\mathrm{tr}\tau ({\log }_2\tau -{\log }_2\sigma )$ if the support of $\tau$ is contained in that of $\sigma$, and $+\infty$ otherwise. Diagonalize the two states with eigenvalues $r_i,s_j$, and put $q_{ij}=|⟨i|j⟩{|}^2$. Each row and column of $q$ sums to one. The elementary scalar inequalityfollows from $x\ln x-x+1\ge 0$, with equality exactly at $x=1$; use limits at zero. ConsequentlyEquality forces $r_i=s_j$ whenever $q_{ij}>0$. Hence every eigenvector $|i⟩$ of $\tau$ is also a $\sigma$-eigenvector with eigenvalue $r_i$, so $\tau =\sigma$. Conversely identical states give zero relative entropy. This proves nonnegativity of quantum relative entropy and its equality condition, including states with zero eigenvalues under the support convention.

Now set $\rho =b{\rho }_1+(1-b){\rho }_2$. For $0<b<1$ its support contains both component supports. Direct expansion givesSince both coefficients are positive, equality holds exactly when both component states equal $\rho$, equivalently ${\rho }_1={\rho }_2$. At either endpoint the mixture has only one component and equality is automatic. This proves the corrected strict concavity of Von Neumann entropy.