Let , and write , with positive integers . If an integer divided both and , then would divide both and , contradicting the maximality of their greatest common divisor . Thus . Equivalently, Bézout's identity for can be divided by to express as an integer combination of .
Divide the divisibility relation by to obtain . Since , multiplication by the modular multiplicative inverse gives . Therefore all integer solutions are , .
The Euclidean algorithm givesso . Since , the criterion for a linear congruence guarantees a solution. One can also exhibit it directly: , or in the original coefficients,Thus is a solution, with an explicit Bézout coefficient certificate.
Let be fresh, not free in any of the three universal premises. Universal quantifier elimination rule gives , and . Apply disjunction elimination rule to the last formula.
In the branch, apply disjunction elimination rule to . Its case contradicts by negation elimination rule, and logical falsity elimination rule then gives . Its case already gives that conclusion. Discharge those two inner case assumptions to obtain under the outer assumption. In the outer branch, the modus ponens rule applied to gives directly.
Discharge the two outer case assumptions by disjunction elimination rule. The conclusion now depends only on the universal premises, in which is not free. Universal quantifier introduction rule therefore gives . All case assumptions have been discharged, and the argument requires no classical reductio ad absurdum.
Choose arbitrary fresh variables and assume under label . The conjunction elimination rule gives and . Apply the disjunction elimination rule to the equality disjunction.
In the case , the supplied symmetry rule gives , and the equality elimination rule applied to gives . Disjunction introduction rule gives . In the case , equality elimination rule applied directly to gives ; the other disjunction introduction rule gives the same conclusion . Discharge the two equality case assumptions by disjunction elimination rule.
Discharge with the implication introduction rule. There are now no undischarged assumptions. Use the universal quantifier introduction rule successively for , then , then , yieldingFreshness holds at every generalization because the sole temporary assumption has already been discharged; the arbitrary variables are not tied to any premise.
Temporarily assume under label . The implication premise and the modus ponens rule yield . Instantiate it at using the universal quantifier elimination rule, obtaining . Its right biconditional elimination rule gives .
Apply the modus ponens rule with the premise to obtain . Together with , negation elimination rule gives . Discharge using the negation introduction rule to conclude . Nothing assumes that the two constant symbols denote different objects; if they denoted the same object, the stated premises would themselves already be inconsistent.
Apply the universal quantifier elimination rule to the universal premise with term , obtaining . The left biconditional elimination rule gives . Use the premise and the modus ponens rule to derive . The existential quantifier introduction rule with witness yields . Substitution of a constant is capture-free here, so both quantifier side conditions hold.
Write . We derive the two disjunction introduction rules and the disjunction elimination rule without using any disjunction rule inside the derivations.
For left introduction, start with and temporarily assume . The conjunction elimination rule gives , and the negation elimination rule gives . Discharge the temporary conjunction by the negation introduction rule, concluding . For right introduction, start with and use the right conjunction elimination rule to obtain instead. Thus either input derives the required encoded disjunction.
For elimination, suppose is available, together with a derivation of from an additional assumption and a derivation of from an additional assumption . Keep their common external context fixed. Temporarily assume under label . Temporarily assume under label and insert the supplied first branch derivation to obtain . Negation elimination rule gives , so negation introduction rule discharges and gives . Repeat with a temporary assumption under label and the supplied second branch derivation, discharging to obtain .
Conjunction introduction rule now gives . Its negation gives by negation elimination rule. The supplied reductio ad absurdum rule discharges and yields . This discharges the two branch assumptions as required and proves the encoded elimination rule. Its last step uses classical propositional logic; the same encoded elimination principle is not generally available in Intuitionistic propositional logic.
Let abbreviate . Suitable rules areTheir derivations require no new axiom. For introduction, apply the conjunction introduction rule to the two premises, obtaining , which is exactly the abbreviation. For left and right elimination, unfold the abbreviation and apply the corresponding conjunction elimination rule. These are therefore derived rules for the NOR connective.
An equivalent subproof presentation of introduction permits one subproof from assumption to and another from assumption to : use the negation introduction rule to discharge each assumption, then apply the conjunction introduction rule. If elimination is desired in contradiction form, combine the left projection with , or the right projection with , using the negation elimination rule. All these presentations reduce directly to the permitted rules.
Assume under label , under label , and under label . A temporary case assumption gives by the modus ponens rule using . A temporary case assumption gives by the modus ponens rule using . The disjunction elimination rule discharges these case assumptions and concludes under .
Apply the implication introduction rule three times, discharging , then , then . The resulting theorem isThe displayed parentheses make explicit the right association of the source formula.
Use the disjunction elimination rule on the outer disjunction. In its left branch, assume and apply the disjunction elimination rule again: from a case assumption , the disjunction introduction rule gives ; from a case assumption , the premise and the modus ponens rule give , then the disjunction introduction rule gives . Discharging those two inner case assumptions yields under the left outer branch.
In the right outer branch, assume . A case assumption gives by the disjunction introduction rule. A case assumption , together with the premise , gives by the negation elimination rule, and then by logical falsity elimination rule. Discharge these inner case assumptions with the disjunction elimination rule.
Both outer branches now have the same conclusion. Discharge the two outer case assumptions with the disjunction elimination rule to obtain under exactly the stated premises.
Keep the four given premises in context and assume under label . The modus ponens rule applied to the first two premises gives and . Apply the disjunction elimination rule to as follows.
Under a case assumption , the premise gives by the modus ponens rule. Together with , the negation elimination rule gives , and the supplied logical falsity elimination rule gives . Under the other case assumption , the required conclusion is already available. Discharge both case assumptions with the disjunction elimination rule to conclude .
Finally discharge with the implication introduction rule, giving . The premise is not needed: a derivation is permitted to leave a premise unused.
Use natural deduction with labelled temporary assumptions. Assume under label , then under label , then under label . Two applications of the modus ponens rule give and . The negation elimination rule gives , and the supplied reductio ad absurdum rule discharges to conclude .
Discharge using the implication introduction rule, obtaining under . Discharge with the implication introduction rule, obtainingAll three temporary assumptions have now been discharged; no premise remains.
No. The nonzero vector is in the kernel of the linear map, so although . A linear map is injective exactly when its kernel consists only of zero.
The reduced row echelon form gives , , and . Taking gives every vector in the null space as . Thus a basis for the kernel of the linear map isDirect multiplication gives . The rank-nullity theorem also checks the count: matrix rank three plus nullity one equals the domain dimension four.
Gaussian elimination gives the row operations , , , producing the lower three rows , , . Subtract the new row two from row three and add three times row two to row four; the remaining nonzero row is . Move it above the zero row and finish elimination to obtainThe pivot columns are one, two and three. Row operations preserve the linear dependence relations among columns, so the corresponding columns of the original matrix form a basis for the column space, which is the image of the linear map:In particular, the matrix rank is three. Columns of the reduced matrix itself would generally give a different subspace, so the original columns must be used.
The first left multiplication swaps rows three and four. The final right multiplication swaps columns three and four, restoring the two diagonal ones to their diagonal positions while exchanging the earlier entries of the two rows. ThereforeThe two specified zeros at positions and are important. Conjugation by this permutation matrix preserves this restricted lower triangular pattern; it would not preserve lower triangularity for an arbitrary matrix with a nonzero entry.
The th column of is . The permutation matrix fixes and interchanges , so these columns are . They are exactly the first, second, fourth and third columns of . Thus right multiplication by interchanges columns three and four, leaving the others unchanged.
Left multiplication by interchanges rows three and four; applying it twice restores every row. Equivalently, it sends the standard basis vectors to each other and fixes , so its square fixes a basis. .
There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.