For proper, the displayed condition is equivalent to being a Frobenius kernel. For a normal subgroup the induction norm is . Trivial inertia for each nonprincipal character and Brauer's permutation lemma imply that every element outside has trivial centralizer in . This forces to be a normal Hall subgroup; a complement is then fixed-point-free on .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 2 2 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
A Frobenius group is a finite transitive group action on more than one point in which a nonidentity element fixes at most one point and a point stabilizer is nontrivial. Equivalently it has a nontrivial proper subgroup with for every . The Frobenius complement is such a point stabilizer .
The Frobenius kernel is the identity together with all fixed-point-free elements in this action, equivalentlyThe Frobenius kernel theorem asserts that this set is a normal subgroup, acts regularly on the points, and gives . In particular for .
Brauer's permutation lemma states that an automorphism of a finite group fixes equally many conjugacy classes and irreducible characters. More generally a group of automorphisms has equal permutation characters on those two sets. Indeed, the character table is invertible and intertwines the two permutation matrices: simultaneous permutation of rows and columns preserves character evaluation. Similar matrices have equal traces, and a permutation-matrix trace counts its fixed points. The fixed objects on the group side are classes, not individual elements.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 2 2 b ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Conversely, the same induction-norm formula shows that for every nonprincipal . Conjugation by each fixes only , so Brauer's permutation lemma says that it fixes only the identity conjugacy class of . A nonidentity element centralizing would provide another fixed class. Therefore for every .
We first prove that and are coprime. If a prime divided both, a Sylow p-subgroup of would have . The nontrivial normal subgroup meets nontrivially: the class equation for the conjugation action of the p-group on makes the number of fixed elements divisible by , and one of them is the identity. Choose and . Then , contradicting the previous conclusion.
Thus is a normal subgroup that is also a Hall subgroup. The Schur-Zassenhaus theorem supplies a group complement , meaning and . The theorem's existence assertion requires only normality and coprimality of order and index. Here is nontrivial and proper by the assumptions on .
For , suppose . Write with . Projection to gives , hence because is injective. This makes centralize , which is impossible. Hence . Writing an arbitrary element outside as reduces its conjugate intersection to this case. It follows that is a Frobenius complement and is a Frobenius group.
Moreover, for each , the map from into the coset is injective, since , and hence bijective. Thus every element outside belongs to a conjugate of , while no nonidentity element of does. The Frobenius kernel is exactly . This completes both directions of the Frobenius kernel criterion by irreducible induction.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 2 2 b i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Suppose first that is the Frobenius kernel. An element fixes a point in the Frobenius action. If , then maps that point to another point fixed by . Since has only one fixed point and acts regularly, . ThusNo nonidentity conjugacy class of can be fixed by such a . If the class of were fixed, for some , so would centralize , a contradiction. Conjugation by consequently fixes just the identity class. By Brauer's permutation lemma it fixes just one irreducible character, necessarily .
For every nonprincipal , its inertia group of a character is therefore . Since is normal, the restriction of the induced character is the sum of its conjugates, counted over :Frobenius reciprocity and character orthogonality giveAn actual character of norm one is irreducible. Every nonprincipal irreducible character of therefore induces irreducibly to .