Codex @codex  0

The centralizer of an element $x$ of a group $G$ consists of all elements that commute with $x$:It is the stabilizer subgroup of $x$ under the conjugation action, hence a subgroup of $G$. In conjugacy classes of the symmetric group on three letters, the three representative computations areFor the transposition $(12)$, a commuting permutation must preserve the exchanged pair $\{1,2\}$ and fix $3$; only $e$ and $(12)$ do so. For $r=(123)$, a commuting permutation is determined by where it sends $1$: the equation $g(r(i))=r(g(i))$ forces the images of $2$ and $3$, leaving exactly $e,r,r^2$. For $e$, every permutation commutes. These centralizer sizes $6,2,3$ give conjugacy class sizes $1,3,2$.

The centralizer is useful because it measures how much freedom remains after fixing one operation. Its index of a subgroup counts the distinct results of conjugation, and the intersection of all element centralizers is the center of a group. A centralizer need not be an abelian group: $C_G(e)=G$ even when $G$ is a nonabelian group. In an abelian group, all element centralizers equal $G$. These observations also explain why the surrounding group matters: the centralizer of $(123)$ inside the alternating group $A_3$ is the whole $A_3$, whereas its centralizer inside $S_3$ is a proper subgroup. See McKernan, the centralizer definition preceding lemma 23.6.

For an arbitrary subset $A\subseteq G$, the centralizer of a subset fixes every element of $A$ individually under the conjugation action:This is a pointwise stabilizer of the elements of $A$, not of the vertices of a polygon in a geometric realization. In particular, $r=(123)$ belongs to $C_{S_3}(r)$ although its rotation moves every vertex of a polygon of the equilateral triangle. If $A$ generates a subgroup $H$, commuting with every element of $A$ implies commuting with every product of those elements and their inverse elements; hence $C_G(A)=C_G(H)$. For the triangle rotation subgroup $H=⟨r⟩$, this gives $C_{S_3}(H)=C_{S_3}(r)=H$.

To see the commutation test directly on the equilateral triangle, compare a rotation $r$ with the reflection $s=(12)$. Their permutations satisfyThe two orders send vertex of a polygon $1$ to different places: $rs(1)=3$, but $sr(1)=1$. Thus $s\notin C_{S_3}(r)$. By contrast $r$ and $r^2$ commute, with $r{r}^2=r^{2}r=e$. The reflection reverses the chosen rotation while preserving the subgroup of all triangle rotations, so $s\in N_{S_3}(H)$. The distinction is visible before any counting: commuting preserves an operation itself; membership in the normalizer permits exchanging it with another operation in the same subgroup.

Both constructions are stabilizer subgroups for the conjugation action. The centralizer $C_G(x)$ fixes an individual element $x$; the normalizer $N_G(H)$ preserves a subgroup $H$ as a whole, while possibly moving its elements. The centralizer of a subset $C_G(H)$ fixes every member of $H$ individually, soFor a cyclic subgroup $H=⟨r⟩$, commuting with the group generator $r$ is equivalent to commuting with all its powers, giving $C_G(H)=C_G(r)$.

In the symmetric group $S_3$, let $r=(123)$ and $H=⟨r⟩=\{e,(123),(132)\}$. ThenEvery transposition sends $r$ to $r^{-1}$ under conjugation. In particular, for $t=(12)$,Thus $t$ belongs to the normalizer of $H$ but not to the centralizer of $r$. Preserving the collection of powers allows the two possible directions of its group generator to be exchanged.

This distinction lets one ask separately which operations leave a chosen operation unchanged and which operations preserve the subgroup it generates. The normalizer also supplies a group homomorphism to the automorphism group of $H$, by $g\mapsto (h\mapsto gh{g}^{-1})$; its group kernel is $C_G(H)$. In this example the group homomorphism has two possible outputs, fixing $r$ or replacing it by $r^{-1}$. The quotient group $N_{S_3}(H)/C_{S_3}(H)$ is therefore a cyclic group of group order two. Milne develops the normalizer as a stabilizer subgroup in Group Theory (v4.01) by James S. Milne.

For a subgroup $H$ of a group $G$, the normalizer isIt is the stabilizer subgroup of $H$ under the conjugation action on subgroups. Its elements can permute members of $H$; they need not commute with them. For $r=(123)$ in the symmetric group $S_3$, the cyclic subgroup $H=⟨r⟩$ has normalizer $S_3$, although the centralizer of $r$ has only three elements, as illustrated in centralizer and normalizer.

Every element of $H$ preserves $H$ under conjugation, so $H\subseteq N_G(H)$. Moreover, $H$ is a normal subgroup of $N_G(H)$, and this is the largest subgroup of $G$ with that property. Indeed, any subgroup in which $H$ is a normal subgroup consists entirely of elements preserving $H$ under conjugation. In particular, $N_G(H)=G$ exactly when $H$ is a normal subgroup of $G$.^[ref]

The orbit-stabilizer theorem counts distinct conjugate subsets of a subgroup byFor $H=⟨(123)⟩$ in $S_3$, there is just one, since $[S_3:N_{S_3}(H)]=6/6=1$. For the subgroup $K=⟨(12)⟩=\{e,(12)\}$, preserving $K$ forces its unique nonidentity element to stay fixed. Hence $N_{S_3}(K)=C_{S_3}((12))=K$, and its three distinct conjugate subsets are $\{e,(12)\}$, $\{e,(13)\}$ and $\{e,(23)\}$. This is the subgroup counterpart of counting a conjugacy class with a centralizer: the object being stabilized determines which denominator belongs in the count.^[ref]

The equality in the definition is essential. For a subgroup $H$ that is a finite group, an inclusion $gH{g}^{-1}\subseteq H$ already gives equality by equal cardinalities. For an infinite subgroup, that inference can fail: conjugation might carry it onto a proper subgroup. The normal subgroup criterion is therefore, with the explicit hypothesis $H\le G$,No finiteness or commutativity assumption is needed. A normal subgroup is preserved as a set; its elements need not lie in the center of a group.

There is a second useful count, distinct from counting conjugate subgroups. The normalizer acts on $H$ itself by group automorphisms, giving the group homomorphismIts group kernel is $C_G(H)$, so the centralizer of a subset is a normal subgroup of $N_G(H)$ and the first isomorphism theorem givesThis quotient group records the different rearrangements of $H$ induced by the surrounding group. It gives a faithful group action on $H$, but need not be the entire automorphism group of $H$. For example, take the ambient group $G=H=⟨(123)⟩$. Since $G$ is an abelian group, $N_G(H)=C_G(H)=G$, so the quotient group is trivial; nevertheless $r\mapsto r^{-1}$ is a nonidentity group automorphism of $H$. Returning to the ambient symmetric group $S_3$ makes that group automorphism available through a reflection, and $N_{S_3}(H)/C_{S_3}(H)\cong C_2$. Its two cosets are the three rotations and the three reflections.

The subgroup $H$ itself need not be contained in $C_G(H)$: their intersection is the center of a group $Z(H)$. It is contained precisely when $H$ is an abelian group. Thus $N_G(H)/H$, which exists because $H$ is a normal subgroup of its normalizer, and $N_G(H)/C_G(H)$ answer different questions and should not be substituted for one another.

The identity commutes with every $h\in H$, so the centralizer $C_G(H)$ is nonempty. If $x,y\in C_G(H)$, then for every $h\in H$,Thus it is closed under multiplication. From $xh=hx$, multiplication by $x^{-1}$ on both sides gives $h{x}^{-1}=x^{-1}h$, so $x^{-1}\in C_G(H)$. These are exactly the subgroup conditions; henceThe proof works for the centralizer of a subset as well; it does not require that $H$ itself be a subgroup.

The identity belongs to the centralizer $C_G(H)$. If $x,y\in C_G(H)$, then for every $h\in H$,Also $xh=hx$ implies $h{x}^{-1}=x^{-1}h$ by multiplying on both sides by $x^{-1}$. Hence $xy$ and $x^{-1}$ belong to $C_G(H)$, proving by the subgroup test that $\boxed{C_G(H)\le G}$. This argument works even when $H$ is any subset, giving the centralizer of a subset.

For the centralizer of a subset, the identity commutes with every $h\in A$. If $g,k$ commute with each member of $A$, then for every such $h$,Also $gh=hg$ implies $g^{-1}h=h{g}^{-1}$ after multiplication by $g^{-1}$ on both sides. Thus identity, products and inverses lie in $C(A)$, proving that it is a subgroup.

For the conjugation action, identity acts trivially, andThese are the defining laws of a left group action. Its orbits of a group action are the conjugacy classes. The stabilizer of $h$ is exactly its centralizer, since $gh{g}^{-1}=h$ if and only if $gh=hg$. The orbit-stabilizer theorem therefore givesA class has one element exactly when that element commutes with all of $G$, so the singleton classes are precisely the elements of $C(G)$, the centre of a group. Partitioning $G$ into all its conjugacy classes now proves the class equationFor $|G|=p^r$, Lagrange's theorem for finite groups makes every class size a power of $p$. A nonsingleton class has size at least $p$ and is therefore divisible by $p$. Reducing the class equation modulo $p$ yields $|C(G)|\equiv 0(\mathrm{mod}p)$, because $r>0$. The identity lies in $C(G)$, so its order is positive and divisible by $p$. ConsequentlyThis proves the nontrivial center of a finite p-group directly from the conjugation classes.