Using a value of the complex logarithm, . Thus every logarithmic-branch value is real and positive:
The principal value is .
Use the exponential definitions of complex sine function and complex cosine. Multiplying the equation by gives , hence . Since exponentials never vanish, this is equivalent to . All branches of the complex logarithm give
The derivation does not divide by , so it introduces no lost zero-denominator cases.
Complex exponentiation uses a branch of the complex logarithm. All logarithms of are with , so
Since the trigonometric factor is always , all values in Cartesian form are
The principal logarithm selects and gives the principal value .
Use the complex exponential forms of the sine and cosine, and put . Multiplying the equation by gives , which simplifies to . Taking all branches of the complex logarithm,
Thus every solution is
The exponential factor used to multiply the equation is nonzero, so no solutions were introduced or lost.
Using the principal complex logarithm, and . Thus the values and their real parts and imaginary parts are
For the final row, first calculate and only then raise this positive real number to the power . Treating nested powers as ordinary real powers would ignore the branching of complex exponentiation.
If all branches are requested, also has the negative of its principal value, and the complex logarithm of is . Allowing nonprincipal logarithms of the positive base gives . Finally, all values of are , for integers as appropriate. These alternatives do not alter the principal-value table.
The values of the complex logarithm at are , . For any such value and any integer ,
This is an integer multiple of , so its sine is zero. In particular the result holds with the principal value . The argument does not require treating the multivalued logarithm as a single globally defined function.
The logarithm's argument is , with complex modulus one. The principal complex logarithm is therefore , giving
If denotes all logarithm values rather than the principal branch, they are for : the real part remains zero and the imaginary part changes by integer multiples of . The principal value is the conventional single-valued answer.
For , the complex logarithm is , where . Consequently
A specified branch chooses one continuous determination of the complex argument on an appropriate cut domain. For the usual principal-value convention use the principal argument . A formula using only would lose the quadrant information; it is a valid local angle only with the appropriate additive multiple of .
Set . The hyperbolic cosine equation becomes , hence . Its two polynomial roots are , both negative. Taking every value of the complex logarithm yields
Since , their real logarithms have opposite signs. All solutions are therefore
The positive real constant is also , the inverse hyperbolic cosine of . Substitution gives for both signs and every integer .
The factor has modulus and principal argument . Multiplication by adds to its complex argument, while the real factor halves its modulus. Hence
Taking the principal logarithm for gives
This complex number lies in the second quadrant. Its modulus follows from the sum of squared components, and its principal argument follows by the second-quadrant correction:
All arguments of this fixed add integer multiples of to the displayed one.
If is interpreted as the multivalued complex logarithm, there is instead a family , where and . Then , and the principal argument is for , or for . This records the logarithm-branch choice that the paper leaves implicit.
Using the exponential definition of hyperbolic tangent, set :
Here , so the resulting points are not poles. Taking all values of the complex logarithm gives . Thus
Equivalently , so these are exactly the imaginary-axis solutions of .
The exponential definition of hyperbolic sine gives , or . Taking every branch of the complex logarithm gives
For hyperbolic cosine, multiply by to obtain . Thus , giving
Take and select a complex argument for . To specify the complex exponentiation, use . Expanding its exponent gives
Its complex logarithm therefore has values
The continuous logarithm obtained by retaining the displayed exponent uses . If the outer logarithm is the principal logarithm, choose to put the imaginary part in instead; the real part is unchanged. In particular one cannot generally assert without checking its imaginary part.
The condition on the real part gives , so the required logarithmic spiral has polar coordinates
As increases, it runs from the negative real axis near radius through , and to the negative real axis at radius . The angle increases by one complete turn. Using the conventional principal argument , the inner negative-axis endpoint is excluded and the outer endpoint is included. The convention reverses those endpoint choices. If both limiting arguments are admitted by the paper's wording, both limiting endpoints are drawn; the interior curve is the same. The origin is never included because the complex logarithm is undefined there.
Figure 1.
One turn of the logarithmic spiral, with an enlarged view near the origin
. Details.
The exponential definitions of hyperbolic sine and hyperbolic cosine, together with Euler's formula, give and . The argument of the complex logarithm therefore reduces to .
Using the principal logarithm, , so
If no branch of the complex logarithm is selected, its complete set of values is , . The real part remains zero, while the imaginary part is . The original paper does not explicitly state a branch convention.
The inner power takes the values . For each such real exponent, all values of the outer complex exponentiation are obtained from all complex logarithm values of its base :
Writing , the answer is
All values lie on the unit circle. The principal choice is , giving . In particular the two nestings in parts (i) and (ii) are different: complex exponentiation is not associative.
Use the full set of complex logarithm values of :
By the definition of complex exponentiation, the inner power can therefore take any value , a positive real number. Its complex logarithm values are , where . Thus
All possible real parts and imaginary parts are consequently
Choosing the principal complex logarithm at both stages gives the particular value . The independent logarithm choices are needed because the question asks for all possible values.
Set . The hyperbolic cosine identity gives , hence the quadratic equation
Let . The first root has modulus and complex argument ; the second has modulus and complex argument . Taking all complex logarithm values gives
The two families are distinct because their real parts are respectively and . This exhausts the solutions because both roots for and all possible complex arguments have been included.
Since with real , necessarily . Use Euler's formula and set . Then
so the quadratic equation gives . Let . It lies on the upper half of the unit circle, so with . Choose the complex logarithm value , taking at . The two roots are , so gives .
Because , this set of real solutions is exactly
The formula includes : the two sign families then coincide after adjusting . No real exists if .
Poles and residues. An isolated singularity is a pole of order if its Laurent series has finitely many negative powers, the lowest being a nonzero multiple of . The residue is the coefficient of .
If and , factor , where is holomorphic near and . For ,
The last quotient is holomorphic and nonzero at , proving a simple pole with
The given function. For noninteger , specify a branch of a multivalued function before using . Choose with , a cut along the negative imaginary axis. This leaves all three roots of off the cut. They are , and , all simple. The numerator is nonzero at these points. Since the denominator has derivative , the residues are
For noninteger , zero is a branch point, rather than an isolated pole. This remains true when and the numerator diverges there. For nonnegative integer it is a regular point. Other logarithm branches change the phases of the residues consistently.
Integral and convergence. Near zero the integrand behaves as , requiring . At infinity it behaves as , requiring . Therefore the exact convergence range is
Use a counterclockwise sector contour with rays at angles and , inner radius and outer radius . The same complex logarithm branch is valid throughout this sector. Only lies inside. The small circular arc contributes and the large one contributes , so both vanish precisely in the stated range.
The outward positive-real ray contributes . On the returning ray set : the denominator is still , while , with reversed limits. The residue theorem gives
Put . The right-hand phase is and . Hence
The sine is positive in this range, consistent with a positive real integral. This is a special case of the Mellin integral of a reciprocal binomial.
For , fix one argument . Every value of the complex logarithm is , . By complex exponentiation, . Taking the real part of its exponent gives all possible moduli:
Equivalently these are . If is real and nonzero the modulus is the single value ; otherwise the values form a geometric progression with ratio . Changing the initially chosen argument just reindexes the same set. The logarithmic definition excludes . This is the modulus of a complex self-power.